Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.5 out of 5
Outstanding | 3212 reviews

What Kathy F doesn't like about Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza:
The food has always been good but the way they resolved a mistake with an online order left a lot to be desired. I used their website to place a takeout order. When I got home I realized 1 of the 4 items ordered was missing. It took 10 mins on the phone to get them to refund my credit card (they initially offered a credit towards a future online order). The manager never got on the phone and the amount refunded didn'... View all feedback. What Marlee Hauck likes about Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza:
Really good pizza and an incredible reward program! We had the roasted cauliflower (picked) and the traditional (based on their regular cheese). Both were delicious. The cheesecake was really good; our children loved it. Totally worth it. The cauliflower was tasty, but would probably order something else next time. We have registered for their reward program after our server has recommended it and are really happy ab... View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Yelp
3.4 ★ from 185 reviews
Mark
04.05.2024 - 14:13

I visited this restaurant for the first time and ordered 12 slices of pizza with pepperoni and a Diet Coke with lemon. There were plenty of tables available and...

read more
Kathy
04.05.2024 - 14:13

The food has always been good but the way they resolved a mistake with an online order left a lot to be desired. I used their website to place a takeout order....

read more
Danielle
04.05.2024 - 14:13

I absolutely adore this restaurant! It's the ideal spot to catch a game. The food is consistently delicious and affordable. The wait staff is friendly and the b...

read more
Chris
04.05.2024 - 14:13

Stopped here to try the pizza. We also grabbed wings . The pizza is served nicely with a hearty portion for 3 if you split it. The wings are large and juicy , I...

read more
Isabella
04.05.2024 - 14:13

The Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza location at this shopping center is excellent. I always make sure to stop by for their delicious meatball sandwich, which puts a...

read more

At Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza, the food shines alongside a vibrant atmosphere that draws crowds. Diners rave about the coal-fired pizza, with offerings like the thick-cut pepperoni and juicy wings stealing the show. The happy hour is particularly popular, featuring freshly made Italian salads and delectable meatballs at great prices. Despite some service hiccups reported, the warmth of the staff often compensates, fostering a welcoming environment. The restaurant’s loyalty program has also garnered praise, with patrons enjoying perks like free pizzas for birthdays. Overall, it’s a go-to spot for delicious food and a lively dining experience.

Menu
5.0 ★ from 2 reviews
Marlee
19.04.2023 - 15:25

Really good pizza and an incredible reward program! We had the roasted cauliflower (picked) and the traditional (based on their regular cheese). Both were delic...

read more
Christa
19.04.2023 - 15:25

Limited menu, but wonderful pizza and salads!

Facebook
4.4 ★ from 1 reviews
Google
4.4 ★ from 500 reviews
Tripadvisor
4.0 ★ from 123 reviews
Doordash
4.6 ★ from 2200 reviews
Int Restaurants
4.3 ★ from 826 reviews
Restaurants
4.0 ★ from 1 reviews

Good Rated Restaurants near Commack

4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Bay Shore (near Commack), 631 E Main St, Bay Shore, United States
"Food was pretty good, but warn, prices are not as published online. Each item was at least one dollar more than listed to our $35 meal in $50"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Syosset (near Commack), 204 Jericho Turnpike, 11791, Syosset, United States
"Delicious as always, I really enjoy their bowls"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Islip (near Commack), 3 Grant Ave, Islip, NY 11751-3500, United States, Afghanistan
"My family and I (vegan) love Sobol. All their smoothies and bowls are vegan without honey, but I don't think their waffles are. They offer vegan prote..."
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: North Massapequa (near Commack), 1064 N Broadway, 11758, North Massapequa, United States
"Freshest and best tasting ices around. So many delicious flavors!"
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.9
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Farmingville (near Commack), 623 Horseblock Road, Farmingville, United States
"I'm from dallas. I never had that. we have blue bell. this place is so great. I've been here 4 times now. it's like soft serve and a snow cone went on..."
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Lindenhurst (near Commack), 678 West Montauk Highway, Village Of Lindenhurst, 11757, United States Of America
"Best ice's"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Smithtown (near Commack), 610 BypassNY 11787, Smithtown, United States
"Great service for a special occasion"
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.5
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Hauppauge (near Commack), 325 Nesconset Hwy Hauppauge, NY 11788, 11788-2500, United States
"The food and service were exceptional!"
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Smithtown (near Commack), 200 W Main St, Smithtown, United States
"Pulled in the Drive-Thru to get a latte and it was dripping all over. When I went to go wipe it off the top was not on correctly and it spilled everyw..."
4.8
Menu
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Open Now
City: Lake Ronkonkoma (near Commack), 239 Hawkins Ave, 11779-4265, Lake Ronkonkoma, United States
"Delicious and healthy. Made a minor mistake on our order today, but took care of it above and beyond. Very classy and proper."