Jersey Mike's Subs - Cincinnati

Fast Food, Sandwiches, Delis

Jersey Mike's has become a mixed bag for patrons, with many praising its standout cold sandwiches, notably the #13 Original, touted as unparalleled in flavor. However, recent price hikes and inconsistencies in service have led some regulars to express disappointment, particularly around takeout orders that fall short of timeliness. While some locations deliver fresh, well-crafted sandwiches and boast friendly staff, others have faced criticism for skimping on ingredients and charging excessive fees for extras. Overall, the atmosphere can be vibrant, but diners should be cautious about the quality and service they've come to expect.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Sara

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.4 / 5 from 7939 reviews

Was Ray A at Jersey Mike's Subs a mag?
The staff was professional and the sandwiches were exceptionally well-made. I ordered a giant 9-inch and a 17-inch, and both were delicious and fresh. Generally, this location consistently delivers quality food. However, the West Lane Avenue branch in Columbus tends to skimp on the meat in their sandwiches. Additionally, at the High Street location in the Short North, if you request extra meat and extra cheese, they... View all feedback.

What Dio Ruiz dislikes about Jersey Mike's Subs:
Been going here a lot the past few months. It was great at first but a few weeks ago they increased the prices and suddenly orders that I place 2-3 hours in advance weren't getting completed until 15-20 minutes after the scheduled time. I work nearby and I get takeout for lunch. I can't afford to waste 15-20 minutes of my lunch break to wait for food I ordered hours earlier especially when the counter isn't even busy... View all feedback.