Goodfellows - Cincinnati

Pizza, Sports , American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Goodfellows

Goodfellows
4.2 / 5 (6459 reviews)

Menu

The restaurant from Cincinnati offers 113 different dishes and drinks on the menu for an average price of $10.6.

Our menu offers a unique and enticing selection of classic and unique pizzas. From traditional cheese or pepperoni to our signature Good Fellow and BBQ Grippo, our pizzas are sure to satisfy. We also have a variety of vegetarian options available. Our sandwiches, such as the mouthwatering meatball sub and classic Daniello, are truly delicious.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: nopath

Images

Goodfellows Food Goodfellows Food Goodfellows Food Goodfellows Food Goodfellows Food Goodfellows Inside Goodfellows Food Goodfellows Food

Feedback

★ 4.2 / 5 from 6459 reviews

Nestled in Cincinnati, this restaurant boasts a varied menu and a welcoming atmosphere, drawing many patrons back for its flavorful pizzas and hearty dishes. While many customers appreciate the friendly staff and fresh ingredients, experiences with service have been inconsistent, ranging from delays in food delivery to issues with incorrect orders. Some diners have had a fantastic time celebrating special occasions, highlighting exceptional dishes like the classic cheese pizza and Italian subs. Despite a few hiccups, regulars recognize improvements post-COVID and cherish its ambiance as a go-to spot for casual dining and late-night bites. Overall, it's a mixed bag but worth a visit.

brian-o-beach0373
23.11.2023

Great experience last night! We had a big group with separate checks and Stormy took care of us! Lots of food and drinks all on the right checks! Best...

amy-l-office8
23.11.2023

Great food and even better service ! Goodfellows knocks it out of the park every time and it doesn't hurt that the bartenders are easy on the eyes ;

chanra-s
23.11.2023

Been coming here since they opened and always well taken care of! Aside from the service from their Bartenders their Pizza is definitely the shining...

nopath
01.10.2024

I ordered food and a draft at the bar. 45 mins later I was asked if I had ordered food. It was packed to go and had been sitting for about 20 mins. That is a service issue but now the fries and bread were soggy. So I ate at the bar out of the to-go boxes The sub was great, classic Italian with wonderful dressing on the side. The Schriber Calzone was also great. Good crust and generous fillings. Fries were inedible through.

marc-hopkins-2
01.10.2024

One of the best pizza places in the city.

  • Sandwiches & Subs

    Bert's Classic Burger
    Bert's Classic Burger
    $8.5
    Jax's Meatball Sub
    Jax's Meatball Sub
    $11.0

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.