Images
Contribute
Reserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What nopath likes about Cincinnati Good Fellows:
I ordered food and a draft at the bar. 45 mins later I was asked if I had ordered food. It was packed to go and had been sitting for about 20 mins. That is a service issue but now the fries and bread were soggy. So I ate at the bar out of the to-go boxes The sub was great, classic Italian with wonderful dressing on the side. The Schriber Calzone was also great. Good crust and generous fillings. Fries were inedible th... View all feedback.
What Thalia Dietrich doesn't like about Cincinnati Good Fellows:
My recent dining experience at this restaurant was not very pleasant. We ordered two pizzas, a salad, and deviled eggs for our appetizer. The salad arrived promptly, followed by one of the pizzas. We had to remind the staff to bring out the rest of our food, and the deviled eggs were served 15 minutes later, with the second pizza arriving 45 minutes after the first. We also had to repeatedly ask for our drinks, despi... View all feedback.
Food here is absolutely awesome. They struggle a little on mixed drinks but everything else is definitely on point.
Ok for the category. Sports bar with a good menu. Service was good. The waiter was busy but managed to check in with us and get the food delivered in a timely manner. The food was ok. We had the pepperoni chips which were burned too much, the cheese pizza which was standard, and the Italian beef which was super dried out with very little au jus. We like Good Fellas but will probably not return to this location.
Ordered a pizza without Pineapple on it, but it came out with Pineapple. Asked for a replacement cause Pineapple is nasty on pizza. So they made me a new one and charge me for half of the messed up one. What a pathetic place to still charge a customer when they make the food wrong!!!! Other then this the waitress was nice.. Management sucks and the owners must as well if this is the practice!!!!!
A bit pricey $80 via Door Dash, omg! pretty close to New York style pizza but why the square cuts, we need to fold our slices Taste is good, got fast delivery definitely would recommend.
All time favorite place to eat at. Wouldn’t want to go anywhere else.
Full Menu
Burger
Pizza Snacks
Pizza
Toppings
Main
Sauces
More information
QR-code link to the menu
