Reviews - Plush Pup
Reviews summary
Plush Pup is a clean, well‑decorated fast‑casual diner with friendly staff, speedy service, and standout items like gyro and Italian beef served in generous portions. Patrons appreciate the classic diner menu, indoor/outdoor seating, and easy parking, though fries can be inconsistent and drinks sometimes small. Recent price increases and reported poor owner interactions have left some customers disappointed. Overall it’s a solid neighborhood quick‑service spot if you’re willing to pay a premium.
Was chris d at Plush Pup a mag?
Still great burgers after all these years! Friendly staff and clean restaurant. Great menu choices of a classic Chicago diner. The fries, on the other hand, are bland and un-salted. Come for everything else on the menu, but skip the French fries. View all feedback.
What Micah S dislikes about Plush Pup:
NEVER AGAIN!!!My family has been supporting Plush Pup for over 5 years. Over time, I have lost my patience with how the owner treats customers. Every single employee is nice and friendly but the owner is rude, sarcastic and arrogant. They will not get one cent from me from this day forward. View all feedback.
Images uploaded by reviewers
Reviews from various users
Last update : 26.01.2024
The gyro meat and fries portion was very generous, especially considering the higher price. The gyro sandwich itself was delicious. The only downside was the smaller-sized regular drink—I was left thirsty after such a hearty meal.
The food at Plush Pup is decent, but the prices are outrageous for the portion sizes. They charge $10 for a hot dog, fries, and a small drink. On top of that, there's a 3.5% fee for credit card payments. You can definitely find better options for much less elsewhere.
I had a wonderful dining experience with amazing food and dishes of the highest quality. Most importantly, the service was exceptional. The gentleman who took my order was extremely kind and polite.
I've noticed that the prices have risen significantly lately, and they've even taken some prices off the menu due to the increases. While the food remains excellent, I can't overlook that the prices seem a bit outdated and are now somewhat on the high side. Will I continue to visit this place? Yes, because it’s convenient and the food is tasty. However, I won’t be coming as often as before. I appreciate the difficulties that small business owners face in trying to manage costs and make a profit, which is why I will continue to support this restaurant. Overall, I still recommend it, though I'm a bit disappointed by the price changes, even if I understand the reasons behind them.
I tried to place an order close to closing time, but unfortunately, the restaurant was out of some of the items we wanted. However, the owner was very apologetic and even came over to greet us by our car. The diner has a charming, no-frills retro vibe. I definitely plan to come back and give it another try.
Last update : 13.08.2023
I wanted to fall in love with this spot, but it doesn't quite meet expectations. Primarily, the food is slightly overpriced for what you receive. The decor is nice. Nothing looks unkempt. Clean place to eat, but I doubt I will return.
NEVER AGAIN!!!My family has been supporting Plush Pup for over 5 years. Over time, I have lost my patience with how the owner treats customers. Every single employee is nice and friendly but the owner is rude, sarcastic and arrogant. They will not get one cent from me from this day forward.
Compared to other same style restaurants this place is insanely high-priced. Plus the lady bringing up the items that barely speaks English is making mistakes and charging more. Years ago this place used to be great, it used to be crowded, last time I went in barely anybody in there. They ripped me off on an item, charged more than it should have been and the lady argued with me about it. I will never go back to this dump again.
This place is seriously good. I wish I lived closer because I would go more often. The gyro I had was phenomenal mostly because their sauce was first rate. Would I go here? Daily if possible. Awesome!
Plush Pup offers American food at its finest! Their menu features exceptional hot dogs, delicious gyros, irresistible Greek chicken, and the largest Italian beef sandwich you’ll ever find. Food: 5/5
Last update : 05.08.2023
Great and tasty food, we had couple orders and all of them are really good, it did take them a bit longer to made order...
Still great burgers after all these years! Friendly staff and clean restaurant. Great menu choices of a classic Chicago diner. The fries, on the other hand, are bland and un-salted. Come for everything else on the menu, but skip the French fries.
Great fast food as advertised. I had the gyro which was tasty, I’d prefer chopped tomatoes, but other than that it was great. The fries were nice a crispy! Easy to get to and park. Staff was very nice. 4.5s!
This place is amazing! Ordered a fish sandwich and some Fries and they gave me a bag full of fries! Haha. The fish sandwich was delicious. I love it
It's been a while since I've had shawarma, so it was a real pleasure to enjoy one again! I wasn't disappointed at all. However, the photo I'm sharing isn't of the shawarma; it's actually of a pork dish I had as my second meal there.
