Marc Anthony's Pizzeria - Catskill

Pizza, Pasta, Pizzeria
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Marc Anthony's Pizzeria

Marc Anthony's Pizzeria
3.6 / 5 (156 reviews)

Description

Nestled in the heart of Catskill, this restaurant has recently experienced a dramatic shift in quality with new ownership. Many patrons lament the decline, citing poorly prepared dishes, long wait times, and inattentive service. Complaints about the inadequacy of salads and soggy subs marred the dining experience for longtime customers. Conversely, recent diners raved about the phenomenal pizza, particularly praising its crisp crust and savory flavors. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive staff were also highlights. Despite the upheaval, opinions remain divided, suggesting a restaurant grappling with inconsistency in its culinary identity. A true gamble for diners seeking quality.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: BoardingPass608435

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 156 reviews
boardingpass608435
17.05.2024

I arrived at the Buger King Store #1834 in Catskills, NY. on 17 SEP 2021 extremly late. I had returned from overseas on Monday and had a really rough week and was heading from NYC towards Vermont to get my son. My vehicle brokedown on the I 87 thruway on a dark dangerous curve. Long story short I took a UBER several upon several miles. In the cab I received a call that my mom passed away. Just before my vehicle had been towed near this Burger King and even though it was closed to people on foot with only drive thru open a young BK employee named Isaac went above and beyond to help me. Thank you so kindly from my heart. As an Army veteran and having an aerospace engineer background I travel alot. Facts It is nice to see positive people in these turbulent times. Awesomeness!

debra-j-patterson
17.05.2024

Good crust, tasty pizza

y1255gwtomg
17.05.2024

I've been a fan of Burger King since the days when it was still called Carrols. For the past few months, I’ve been enjoying their $5.00 meals for lunch; they were just the right size—not too big and not too small. However, today I discovered that the meal deal has changed. Now, you'll need to spend more than the $5.40 at the pay window. The soda is no longer included in this new $6.00 "Your Way Deal," and while the other items are similar, they don't quite match my previous favorites. If you want to add a small drink, your total will be $8.50, including tax, which is three dollars more. Thanks, Uncle Joe.

patricia-kane-handel
17.05.2024

I just enjoyed two slices of pizza here. The crust was outstanding, and the sauce was top-notch. I will definitely return!

bobbie-jo-c-2
17.05.2024

Lousy service. Lady at counter very snotty. Pizza in the display looked old. I asked for cheese lady said not right now we where slammed alittle while ago. My daughter just got a slice out of the display sat down. A couple came in ask for slices she said she will make them some. They pick and choose what Customers they want to get the stuff for. Never coming back!

FAQ

The restaurant offers complimentary WiFi for its customers.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.