Reviews
What Ronny Ankunding doesn't like about Carle Place Diner:
great food. beautiful old diner. my children loved the mickey mouse pfannkuchen. my man loved the main rib and said it was juicy and tender. the French toast was just fine. not much taste. friendly staff. View all feedback. What Jennings Lynch likes about Carle Place Diner:
Overall, the food was okay. The food of the children was good, but my main dish (lead sludge) was dried out and shattered in the severity to cover it. It wasn't terrible, but it wouldn't suggest. Service was excellent and they were very courteous and helpful, I was alone with 3 of my 5 children. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Eating was at best average, the gravy and icy had almost no taste. I had asked if they were freshly brewed icy and I was told, yes, when I got it, it was obviou...
read moreVery disappointed in my order tonight. ordered a Mediterranean salate that was missing the half of the ingredients. I was charged $22. I called to ask if they h...
read moreThis place is well staffed and the food and desserts in the display look fantastic. I had the fish and chips and they were bland. The fries were frozen and so w...
read moreI stopped here for a light dinner, ordered scrambled eggs, pancakes and bacon. Eggs and pancakes were great bacon was inedible. Like cardboard. When I told the...
read moreHad the Challah French toast not great. Wasn’t terrible but also not worth finishing my plate. Kind of dry. The waitress also recommended the carrot cake so we...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe Carle Place Diner offers diners a retro vibe reminiscent of classic establishments. While some dishes, like the fried chicken and cheesesteak egg rolls, receive praise for their freshness and flavor, others, such as the Challah French toast and Mediterranean salad, fall short, with complaints of dryness and missing ingredients. Service remains a highlight, with attentive staff dedicated to providing a warm, friendly atmosphere. Despite the occasional culinary misstep, the diner maintains a loyal following thanks to its nostalgic charm and a menu that caters to diverse tastes, making it a noteworthy stop for comforting American diner fare.
This restaurant is amazing. I adore the ambiance and decor. The waitress was extremely friendly and the owner greeted us warmly and bid us farewell. The food wa...
read moreI visited a restaurant that had a jukebox on the table - how cool! I really enjoyed the retro vibe of the place, the impeccable service, the friendly staff, and...
read moreThe eggs were almost completely finished. That's okay because the service was fantastic. Very diner must season food to your taste.
The service was fast and friendly from the moment I sat down to when I paid. The restaurant was very clean too. I have missed this type of diner since moving aw...
read moreI was very happy with greeting, service and food. The food itself was high quality and was also prepared with great taste. The staff was all informative and the...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more