Reviews
What Linda Rice Bailey doesn't like about Mayer's Tavern:
It was a horrible experience. We waited over an hour for a 6 party. After we waited over an hour, we changed the res to 2, since the other 4 of our party couldn't handle the horrible noise from the girls singing off key guitar playing. They then said it would be now another hour since we were just a party of 2. Forgot it. There are so many other great places to eat in Cape May. Don't go there. View all feedback. What DJ Smith likes about Mayer's Tavern:
The best meal I’ve had in Cape May in 10+ years First sign of a top tier experience is the service of COLD water. Everything we ordered was exceptional. Service was great. The brioche bread pudding was the best dessert I’ve had in Cape May, until I tried the peach crumble special. Both memory making desserts to cap off a 10/10 meal. Not pictured: fried scallops, PEI mussels, fried calamari all fire. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
We had a fantastic evening at this welcoming restaurant that feels like a cozy pub, with a focus on fresh food! We enjoyed the concise menu that offers somethin...
read moreThis place is a bit of a dive bar with live music, but the food is pretty good. The inside dining area is small with seating at the bar, and there is also outsi...
read moreI have never had any problems with the food at this restaurant, but the service and policies have been issues in the past. I visited on April 19th and everythin...
read moreLovely casual spot. Excellent scallops. Pleasant staff. Nice outdoor seating. Highly recommended
Pretty solid food! Amazing scallops. Bartenders were nice and the service was very good. Had a great seat near the corner of the bar so we had an easy time talk...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThe restaurant offers cozy and inviting atmosphere with live music in a dive bar setting. While the limited menu includes seafood options like scallops and fried seafood dishes, some found the breading overpowering while others enjoyed the fresh and flavorful seafood. Reviews mention excellent service and creative drink selection, but some note high drink prices. The small dining space can be challenging for larger groups. Overall, the restaurant is praised for its fresh and delicious food, cozy ambiance, and friendly service, making it a hidden gem with a spectacular view of the sunset.
It was such a nice experience with good food and drinks! We watched the sunset from the deck seating and although the menu is small everyone found something we...
read moreThe best meal I’ve had in Cape May in 10+ years First sign of a top tier experience is the service of COLD water. Everything we ordered was exceptional. Service...
read moreAte there last night for the third time I seem to get more disappointed as I eat here They read about the scallops, but lately all you get is more potatoes unle...
read moreIt was a horrible experience. We waited over an hour for a 6 party. After we waited over an hour, we changed the res to 2, since the other 4 of our party couldn...
read moreLove it. My wife loved the burger,I loved the scallops. Nice atmosphere. Great service. Home made fries. Yum .
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more