Italiano's Pizza - CAPE MAY

The pizza we had at this restaurant was dry, tasteless, and seemed like it had been sitting out all day. We purchased three slices for $15.00 at 9:00 a.m. and were very disappointed. We will not be returning. Unfortunately, Louie's has lost a loyal customer.

This pizzeria is a small, traditional spot run by one man. It is welcoming and located right by the water. It is one of the few places open during the offseason and open after 3pm. The delicious smell drew us in, and we were pleasantly surprised to receive free garlic knots as soon as we arrived. The option to dine outdoors or indoors was nice. The owner seems very eager to feed his customers, giving off a nostalgic vibe reminiscent of old school places in Connecticut or New York City. This is definitely a must-visit for anyone looking for great pizza, as one slice is enough for a satisfying meal.

The staff was incredibly kind to my boyfriend and me, even offering us complimentary garlic knots. I was surprised to find that the pizza had a thicker crust than I had anticipated.

The large' pizza will feed a small army. Good stuff (the crust is a yummy bready type). I'd avoid the salad...not worth the and won't need it with the monster pizza!

Louie's Pizza 7 Gurney Street/ off 711 Beach Street Cape May. Again, this is the one just off the corner of Beach Street and across from the Beach in Cape May, NJ Enjoyed an amazingly tasty thick crusted, crunchy, pizza at Louie's Pizza. Hefty, totally-satisfied-and-filling' thick slices at this very informal, vest-pocket, recessed, eatery. Blinked and almost missed-out on enjoying this nice treat due to the almost hidden, recessed view. Very gracious and friendly counter person. Can't wait to go back on our next visit.