Subway Shop - Brooklyn

Breakfast, Lunch, Sandwiches

Subway Shop

Subway Shop
3.5 / 5 (199 reviews)

Menu

A comprehensive menu of Subway Shop from Brooklyn featuring all 1 dishes and drinks can be found here on the list.

**A Hidden Gem: Casual Dining at Its Best** Nestled in a gas station, this charming eatery boasts a small but inviting atmosphere. Diners rave about the exceptional food quality, particularly the exquisite Baja ranch dressing. Most reviews highlight the efficient service, where friendly staff enhance the experience, though some encounters reflect a need for improved customer interactions. While offered options can vary, and occasional shortages are reported, the restaurant's cleanliness and cheerful vibe create a welcoming dining experience. Ideal for a casual outing, this spot is perfect for grabbing a sub while enjoying lively music, making it a must-visit for fans of simple, satisfying fare.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Lawrence

Images

Subway Shop Food Subway Shop Menu

Feedback

★ 3.5 / 5 from 199 reviews

Was Jacinthe Hodkiewicz at Subway Shop a mag?
The underground setting was nice, and the service was generally good. I did notice that there was a slight shortage of the vegetables I ordered, though I didn’t specifically request more. Overall, the restaurant was clean and had a welcoming atmosphere. View all feedback.

What Jerry Stout dislikes about Subway Shop:
I want to emphasize that any review with fewer than five stars isn't worth considering. Food: 10/10 (the Baja ranch was especially amazing). Service: 10/10 (the restaurant was spotless, and the straightforward, efficient way the woman at the counter prepared my sandwich added a delightful charm to the experience that’s difficult to put into words). View all feedback.

ericks-williams
12.02.2024

I-80 puts travelers in a difficult situation. Why are your truck stops open 24 hours, but the food service isn't? Not everyone works a typical 12-hour day shift! This particular truck stop should think about accommodating customers at all hours.

mhodkiewicz
28.10.2022

The underground setting was nice, and the service was generally good. I did notice that there was a slight shortage of the vegetables I ordered, though I didn’t specifically request more. Overall, the restaurant was clean and had a welcoming atmosphere.

jerry-stout-4
12.02.2024

I want to emphasize that any review with fewer than five stars isn't worth considering. Food: 10/10 (the Baja ranch was especially amazing). Service: 10/10 (the restaurant was spotless, and the straightforward, efficient way the woman at the counter prepared my sandwich added a delightful charm to the experience that’s difficult to put into words).

lawrence-hanson-snak
12.02.2024

I visited Subway Shop for both lunch and dinner on October 3, 2021. Lunch was excellent—the staff were friendly, and the food tasted just like Subway. However, dinner was a different experience. This location closes at 8 PM, which I understand due to labor issues. I arrived around 7:45 PM, waited in line, ordered, and began eating. The employee, who introduced himself as Nivek, initially used what looked like rotisserie chicken for my chicken bacon ranch sub. It wasn’t a major issue, so I simply requested the regular chicken, which he replaced—but he displayed a bad attitude afterward. While ringing me up, he checked the time and complained about customers showing up last minute, even though my receipt was stamped 7:50 PM. Shortly after, at 7:57 PM, another customer entered and began ordering. Nivek immediately responded in an argumentative tone, saying they couldn’t make any more subs as he had already closed the register. The customer replied similarly, and the situation quickly escalated. I stood up for the customer because Nivek shouldn’t be complaining about patrons right in front of them.

mariah-h-bush533
12.02.2024

I went to Subway Shop tonight to order two subs. They were out of the meat for one of them, so I chose a different kind. Then, I asked for American cheese on one and shredded cheese on the other, but they said they only had provolone left. I decided to cancel the order, and the woman got very rude, throwing the first sub into the food aggressively. When another customer stepped up, she asked who’s next but was unfriendly, refusing to list all the items they were out of, saying she’d only inform if asked. Overall, her attitude was very unpleasant.

Menu

  • This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.