Mitchell's Steak Seafood - Brookhaven

#3 - Seafood - Brookhaven, Steak, American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Mitchell's Steak Seafood

Mitchell's Steak Seafood
3.6 / 5 (45 reviews)

Description

Nestled conveniently off the interstate, this restaurant presents a stark contrast of experiences for diners. While some guests rave about the tender filet and attentive service, others report disappointment with untrained staff and inconsistent food quality. Complaints frequently mention subpar steaks and delayed orders, particularly for appetizers like the acclaimed spinach and artichoke dip. Yet, many patrons appreciate the variety on the menu and the inviting atmosphere. The efforts of friendly staff members, such as Ken, who takes the time to check on guests, often brighten the experience. Overall, this dining spot promises potential but leaves room for improvement.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Alexander

Feedback

★ 3.6 / 5 from 45 reviews
bhernandes
22.01.2023

My wife and i tried this restaurant for the first time last night. we felt like we totally out of sync with the staff. our server was polite but untrained. it was a major ordeal to get some sugar. the steak that i received was truly a dried out piece of leather that tasted like old venison. my wife's steak was a deep fried Grissel with a tangy flavor. now to the good news. the salad,veggies and water were perfect. even though i paid $10.00 for them. the night manager was puzzled on how to help us with our meal.. her offer of a free desert as she looked at 2 plates of uneaten food was taken as a joke but wasn't. in today's tight budget climate i would strongly recommend that when the cook and manager are out of town that he put someone with more experience in charge

okon-marcelo
22.01.2023

My partner and I stopped here during a Sunday trip, and we had a great experience. The food was excellent, and the menu offered a nice variety of options. We will definitely return the next time we are in the area. We are from the Baton Rouge area in Louisiana, and this restaurant could easily compete with the best places back home. Plus, it's conveniently located right off the interstate.

okon-marcelo
22.01.2023

My wife and I dined at your restaurant tonight (1-21-11) and were quite disappointed with the service we received. I requested the Spinach and Artichoke dip twice, but it never arrived. My husband ordered a medium-cooked steak, but it came out well done and was tough as leather. Additionally, when my husband inquired about having fried eggplant instead of the salad, the waitress informed him that it would be an extra charge. He decided he would prefer the salad, yet she still included the eggplant in our order and charged us for it. Although she mentioned that the bread was on the way twice, it only arrived as we were finishing our meal.

jframi-2
22.01.2023

I have been many times and have never been disappointed! My food is always cooked to perfection and I make a point to try different items on the menu. Ken is a very friendly person and is always making an effort to make rounds throughout the restaurant checking on each table making sure each patron is happy and without complaint. Couldn't ask for a better place to dine!

antonio-hills
22.01.2023

Kitchen is run by a bunch of kids. Charged me 10 dollars for a huge bowl of cheese and artichoke sauce, but only gave me six small wedges of bread and charged me double when I asked for simply more bread.

FAQ

You can use the WLAN of the restaurant free of charge.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.