Big Pine Rooster
Big Pine Rooster
Menu
The menu of Big Pine Rooster from Big Pine comprises about 181 different menus and drinks. On average you pay about $13.8 for a dish / drink.
Big Pine Rooster has garnered a mixed yet intriguing reputation among diners. While the diverse menu, featuring standout dishes like Lobster Mac and Thai Chili Shrimp, delights many, service inconsistencies have raised concerns. Reports of delayed meals and communication issues with staff suggest a need for better training. Yet, amidst these challenges, the restaurant's commitment to homemade dishes shines through, distinguishing it from the typical frozen fare found in the area. With its rich flavors and generous portions, Big Pine Rooster remains a noteworthy culinary stop, though patience may be required for a fulfilling dining experience.
Images
Reservation request for Big Pine Rooster
Feedback
Was Linda Flegal at Big Pine Rooster a mag?
What a delightful family-friendly restaurant! We really enjoyed the benches with cushions—they were so comfortable! The food was fantastic; we tried both the grilled and blackened yellowfin, and both were delicious! The Key Lime Pie was also very tasty! Our server, Bobby, was incredibly nice. Despite being one of only two servers managing the entire restaurant, he worked diligently while always wearing a smile and ta... View all feedback.
What StefanieW dislikes about Big Pine Rooster:
The fish dip was delicious, although the seasoning on the seafood was a bit too spicy for my taste—it really took my breath away. That said, there were plenty of options to choose from! View all feedback.
The waitress was very friendly, but the restaurant itself didn't live up to expectations. I had read all the positive reviews and decided to give it a shot. Unfortunately, my burger had an overwhelmingly gamey flavor and I couldn't finish it, so I sent it back. I wasn’t given the option to reorder. The conch fritters were burnt, but we picked off the charred bits and ate what we could since we were hungry and tired after walking all day. To top it off, we were never offered a drink refill, so we ended up sitting with empty glasses throughout our meal.
For vegetarians, there were plenty of options available. The staff were knowledgeable and attentive when it came to accommodating my dietary restrictions, offering gluten-free options and modifications. Additionally, they were very friendly and patient with my children, making it a kid-friendly environment.
We came here after finding No Name pub too crowded, and I was blown away! I didn't expect the food to be this amazing. I'm staying in the area for a month, and I plan to return as often as I can—I'm even coming back for breakfast tomorrow morning. Truly fantastic! It's far better than anything else I've tried here, not even a comparison. Be sure to ask for Sol; she's excellent!
Menu
Main
Bucky's SkilletOur fresh cut & grilled potatoes + sautéed peppers & onions; bacon; cheese & 2 eggs your way
$9.9
Huevos PescadorDoesn't get better than this folks! Big flour tortilla + rice & beans topped + a fresh local Mahi filet; bronzed + 2 eggs your way; then add cheese & salsa! Sour cream & jalapenos on the side
$15.8
Bucky's Breakfast TacosFluffy scrambled eggs; bacon; ham; sweet onions; green peppers; & melted cheddar jack cheese all nestled in 3 flour tortillas sided + fresh salsa fruit!
$9.9Tasty Appetizers
Keys BreadRooster's favorite! A mix of Bleu & other melted cheeses; garlic; fresh tomato & more
$8.9
Homemade Mozzarella PlanksLightly fried Amazing! Zesty marinara for the dipper
$10.9Greens 'N' Stuff
Pan Tossed Bronzed Shrimp 'N Scallop Salad$17.8
More information
QR-Code for the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 3.7 / 5 (1508 reviews)Chinese Delivery Services Asian SoupChina Garden
Key Deer Boulevard 209, 33043 BIG PINE KEY, US
"Sweet and sour chicken was very good!"
★ 4.7 / 5 (654 reviews)Seafood American Bars AmericanSquare Grouper
Sugarloaf Key & Boca Chica Key, Mile 22.5 oceanside, 33042-4221, SUMMERLAND KEY, United States
"Absolutely amazing! I wish I could give it 6 stars. I had the seafood stew and tried some of the other dishes, and they were all to die for. I can't e..."
★ 3.9 / 5 (22680 reviews)Seafood Drinks American Casual CateringMangrove Mama's
Overseas Highway 19991, 33042 SUMMERLAND KEY, US
"Conch fritters delish and the best key lime pie!"