Jackie Reilly's from Bethpage Menu

What User likes about Jackie Reilly's:
I've visited this restaurant many times in the past, but not since the pandemic. Usually, I only have one friend who can join me. It’s a wonderful, welcoming Irish pub-style eatery! They offer a fantastic variety of chicken, steak, and pork dishes, but my friend and I always loved their Shepherd’s Pie the most! It’s freshly made and topped with delicious mashed potatoes. The waitstaff is Irish, very helpful, and frie... View all feedback.

What User doesn't like about Jackie Reilly's:
A cpl drink n apps ordered. My drink tasted like watered Bacardi n coke n the food was soo boiled. We sent the chicken pliers back and I ate my potato skins only bc I starved, they were not very gd tho. They seem to be understaffed bc our waitress was constantly on the go n was not able to give every table the attention everyone deserves. The interior is nice n clean. View all feedback.

A cpl drink n apps ordered. My drink tasted like watered Bacardi n coke n the food was soo boiled. We sent the chicken pliers back and I ate my potato skins only bc I starved, they were not very gd tho. They seem to be understaffed bc our waitress was constantly on the go n was not able to give every table the attention everyone deserves. The interior is nice n clean.

Beautiful old school Irish pub. denk an nyc irish pub. reason for 3 stars I ordered eating from the website menu (big wing btw) and all prices were different when I picked up my order? Maybe they need to update their website prices. alittle expensive for eating. the wings were great, everything else was so. spent over 50dollars for 3 appetizers. it looks like I'm returning for the wings.

Today with my great friend noel! sean reilly and those of the bartender help us for over 25 years. the best!

We were here for a birthday party. only for a few minutes. wein served was ok. wait staff very nice accommodation.

I had fish and chips which were both cooked to crunchy perfection. The owner personally came to talk with us and he is the best. Service was awesome.

Feedback