Cup - Bethlehem
Cup
Description
The Cup delivers generous, homemade ice cream in an old‑fashioned, neighborhood shop with an extensive flavor roster — from a chunky Cookie Monster to a memorable blueberry cheesecake. Retro arcade games entertain (one can win a free sundae) and prices feel fair for the portions. It’s a popular campus‑area hangout that can get busy during the school year. Most service is friendly, though staff can sometimes seem reserved, and the shop doesn’t open until noon.
Images
Feedback
If you're familiar with The Bethlehem Dairy Store, this is its sister location. They offer all the same delicious ice cream, with just a few flavors missing. This spot features retro arcade games, and one of them allows you to win a free sundae. The service is consistently friendly, and I highly recommend visiting for their homemade ice cream!
The ice cream flavors are incredible! We tried the blueberry cheesecake, and it was fantastic. The prices are impressive considering the generous portions of ice cream you receive!
This place is the go-to for ice cream, but they don’t open until noon, which is quite inconvenient, especially on a college campus. This leads to them missing out on a lot of business. Also, it would be nice if the employees smiled a bit more from time to time.
More information
QR-Code for the menu

