Albert's Pizza Bayshore - Bay Shore

Went in today for a quick bite with my wife. Ordered a large cheese pie. They said 15 minutes. It was 15 minutes. We got two 20oz snapples. All for the surprising price of $15. We got home, ate the pie and it was delicious. Friendly staff. Freely offered paper plates too. Will be returning back with the family. Next to Kohl's and Hobby Lobby.

Good buffalo chicken, good grandma slice nice place to go friendly people.

I've been going to Albert's for 30+ years. My husband's been going for ~50 years. So glad they branched out. Love Alberts original pie! Tastes like no other pie around.

4/8/18 3:50pm Not sure who took my girlfriends order just now but whoever the gentleman is, was extremely professional. Most of the time we call around for pizza everyeones usually rude or in a rush. Never give us out totals or ask if we want anything else but this guy defied that average. My girlfriend was on speaker phone so I overheard the conversation and by the time it was over we were both really impressed. Not only did the man take the order seamlessly he added up the items, gave us a total and also asked if we wanted any extras such as sauces or sides. I appreciate this and it goes a long way in my book. I usually pay for everything and let her handle the ordering since I'm usually working. (16 hours a day, 6 days a week) during that time she usually orders dinner and stuff when I'm driving home. When she orders I want her to be respected and appreciated as a customer. There should be no reason to get anxiety ordering food but certain places leave her a little bent out of shape after their service and Alberts deffinetly isn't in that category. Thank you guys, you have no idea how much easier you made my eating life with your generosoty, patience and hospitality. You da bomb diggity.

We have tried over 20 pizza places throughout the years, and one thing that has bothered us on Long Island is the misconception that NYC pizza is made with cheap ingredients and therefore not as delicious. This idea is ignorant to the fact that the world associates 'NYC Pizza' with a unique and tasty flavor. Albert's Pizza is the closest we have found to the classic city pizza that New Yorkers grew up on, and they even use real cheese (which they advertise on their boxes), making the pizza even better. For the price and taste, Albert's Pizza is truly exceptional. The staff is always respectful and willing to make a fresh pie up to 15 minutes before closing time. Even though it is a bit further away than our nearest pizzeria, we still consider Albert's our favorite place for pizza.