Menu - Third And Main

The bread service was underwhelming; I anticipated warm bread, but instead, it was cold, chewy, and lacking in flavor. My partner's 10oz Wagyu NY Strip seemed t... read more The bread service was underwhelming; I anticipated warm bread, but instead, it was cold, chewy, and lacking in flavor. My partner's 10oz Wagyu NY Strip seemed thinly cut and had more gristle than we expected. My filet was decent, and I appreciated the pink peppercorn tallow topping, while the mashed potatoes were good. My main issue with the food was the limited variety of side options; not everyone prefers mashed potatoes or a vegetable dish. When comparing prices with Ruby’s or Losanti, I don’t think I would make the trip back to Third and Main, unfortunately.

This past Saturday was my very first time visiting Third and Main. Prior to these reservations that were made last minute, we had plans of going somewhere more... read more This past Saturday was my very first time visiting Third and Main. Prior to these reservations that were made last minute, we had plans of going somewhere more local to us. We live in Amelia, Ohio. So, this was an hour drive one way. The reason we chose to go here was for one, we were celebrating two birthdays as well as we heard the food was phenomenal. Not only was the food beyond delicious, our service was top notch which is hard to find at most restaurants. We were seated almost immediately, served by an amazing waitress named Hailey who went above and beyond explaining the menu and different types of steaks to our party of 4. We were also asked by several different people if there was anything they could get for us which made the service that much more meaningful! Since our dinner Saturday, we have raved and recommended this 12/10 restaurant to all of our family and friends! Can’t wait to return!!!!