Pizza 72 - Aurora

Some earlier reviews said this pizza rivals New York-style, but I have to disagree. The crust was the best I’ve had all summer while traveling, yet the cheese w... read more Some earlier reviews said this pizza rivals New York-style, but I have to disagree. The crust was the best I’ve had all summer while traveling, yet the cheese was only mediocre and didn’t have the gooey texture I expected. The garlic knots were tasty, though the cold dipping sauce was a bit disappointing.

I ordered the family meal deal tonight through DoorDash since the restaurant is a bit far from me. The pizza was incredibly delicious, with all the flavors blen... read more I ordered the family meal deal tonight through DoorDash since the restaurant is a bit far from me. The pizza was incredibly delicious, with all the flavors blending perfectly. The garlic knots are among the best I've ever tasted in Denver. We'll definitely be ordering again and look forward to visiting in person. Keep up the great work!

I’ve ordered from Pizza 72 several times and overall, I’d give it three stars. The dough and sauce are great, and my first couple of orders were excellent. Howe... read more I’ve ordered from Pizza 72 several times and overall, I’d give it three stars. The dough and sauce are great, and my first couple of orders were excellent. However, my last two experiences have been disappointing. Most recently, I ordered an XL pizza and boneless hot buffalo wings, but received regular wings instead. When I mentioned this at the counter after paying, nothing was done. Since no one in my household eats wings with bones, the meal felt incomplete. Also, the pizza wasn’t as good as usual. Previously, the pizza was fantastic, but the garlic knots were dry and overcooked, and the boneless wings lacked sauce. I had high expectations based on my initial orders, but the recent ones fell short.

I visited for the first time, and it certainly won't be my last. I ordered a Sicilian pizza, which was quite generous for just the two of us. I really loved the... read more I visited for the first time, and it certainly won't be my last. I ordered a Sicilian pizza, which was quite generous for just the two of us. I really loved the crust; it wasn't too thick and was full of delicious flavors. This restaurant is locally owned, and the staff was wonderful.

I visited this restaurant for the first time and was truly impressed! The pizza was outstanding—wow! The staff was fantastic—quick and friendly. I highly recomm... read more I visited this restaurant for the first time and was truly impressed! The pizza was outstanding—wow! The staff was fantastic—quick and friendly. I highly recommend this place and will definitely return!