The Stone Yard - Appleton

Pizza, American, North American
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

The Stone Yard

The Stone Yard
3.5 / 5 (1120 reviews)

Menu

A complete menu of The Stone Yard from Appleton featuring all 23 dishes and drinks can be found here on the menu.

Discover The StoneYard, a beloved American restaurant in Appleton, WI, boasting an average rating of 3.8 stars. Open daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM, this charming eatery is the perfect spot for satisfying your cravings. To check on availability or reserve a table, simply call (920) 968-0222. For added convenience, you can also enjoy your favorite dishes from The StoneYard through Uber Eats. In addition to a diverse menu, don’t miss out on their excellent selection of beers. If you're looking for other dining options with a similar vibe, consider visiting Jaripeo Mexican Grill or Neighborhood Beer Garden. Have you dined here before? Share your experience by leaving a review!.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: User

Images

The Stone Yard Food The Stone Yard Food The Stone Yard Food The Stone Yard Food The Stone Yard Outside The Stone Yard Menu The Stone Yard Outside The Stone Yard Outside

Feedback

★ 3.5 / 5 from 1120 reviews

The Stone Yard offers a varied menu with decent options like pulled pork and pizza, alongside an impressive beer and drink selection. However, service remains inconsistent, particularly for new customers who may feel overlooked as staff prioritize regulars. Reviews indicate persistent kitchen issues, leading to incorrect orders and a lack of attention to detail. Positive experiences have been noted, especially regarding the All You Can Eat Tacos and attentive servers during less busy times. Overall, patrons see potential in the restaurant but urge for improvements in service and food quality before a more frequent return.

susan-van-camp
10.10.2023

Enjoyed our time at the StoneYard, while visiting relatives. Actually had a group of 50 people, which was easy to talk, hear each other. Bartenders were attentive to the request.

carol-herminath
10.10.2023

Hi was there wed night food was good bartender was not friendly had to ask for the check never got acknowledged like we were invisible he was obviously not wanting to be there! Doesn't make us want to come back which is sad it's a great place need improvement on his part he was not busy either which makes it worse

terry-wirth
10.10.2023

My party and I dined at The Stone Yard on a busy Saturday afternoon on September 17, 2022. While the place wasn't overly crowded, two out of three of our orders were mixed up. My brother-in-law had ordered a Reuben with Texas toast instead of the regular toast, but it was made incorrectly with the wrong type. He also had to remind the staff twice for Thousand Island dressing. I ordered a Texas toast burger with bacon, but unfortunately, there was no bacon on my burger, and the patty was unusually small, only covering half of the toast. I noticed the waitress was attentive while taking our orders, so I believe she did her part correctly. Our server was very helpful, though I regret not catching her name. I assured her that the mistakes weren't her fault. I've heard that The Stone Yard is under new management, but issues like these have been persistent for at least a month. I recommend looking into the kitchen operations, as they can significantly affect your business's success. Right now, I'm not very eager to come back, but I might reconsider in a few months to see if any improvements have been made.

Hi was there wed night food was good bartender was not friendly had to ask for the check never got acknowledged like we were invisible he was obviously not wanting to be there! Doesn't make us want to come back which is sad it's a great place needimprovement on his part he was not busy either which makes it worse

justin-burton-1
16.08.2024

We stopped in and it was not overly crowded nor were we given a heads up from our server about possible long wait. We ordered our food and an appetizer, 1.25 hours later we had nothing, not even an appetizer or an update on our food. We left and ate at Kwik Trip. I have given this place many opportunities and supported it during COVID, unfortunately it has never gotten any better. I would only stop in only for drinks going forward as the kitchen is a train wreck. Sad because there aren't many options on the north side and they could really do well.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.