Sal's Pizza - Appleton

#1 - Order Pizza Appleton, Cheese, Bbq

Sal's Pizza

★ 4.7 / 5 (285 reviews)

+19209554444

The restaurant is also easily accessible by municipal transit. The closest stop is Greyhound-Appleton, just 476 meters away, Otherwise, there are parking spots available at a distance of 112 meters at City of Appleton-Parking Garage.

Foodmash

No food images left in this area

Would you like to see the best rated food in this area?

Appleton

Amenities

Delivery Outdoor Seating Delivery Service Takeout No Reservations Limited Parking

Sal's Pizza in Appleton has garnered a loyal following thanks to its generous slices, flavorful garlic rolls, and friendly service. While many patrons rave about the pizza's quality and variety, recent price increases have left some customers feeling disheartened. The cozy atmosphere and clean facilities add to its appeal, making it a must-visit spot for both locals and visitors. Deliveries face occasional hiccups, but management's responsiveness is commendable. Overall, Sal's remains a favorite destination for satisfying pizza cravings in the area.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Matt

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 4.7 / 5 from 285 reviews

Was User at Sal's Pizza a mag?
This cake is absolutely amazing! I indulged in the slices and the bread roll. Whenever I'm in Appleton, this is a go-to spot for me! The sauce is fantastic, the cheese is perfectly balanced, and the dough is incredible. You’ve got to try it! View all feedback.

What Al S dislikes about Sal's Pizza:
We have been regulars at Sal’s for as long as they have been at their Appleton location, until our last visit! They always provided good food(we each get a slice and a soda), very friendly service and usually pleasant music all at a reasonable price! We suffered sticker shock at our last visit, being charged $17.00 for what we would usually cost us $12.50! That’s a 35% increase in price!!! We have been faithful custo... View all feedback.

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

This cake is absolutely amazing! I indulged in the slices and the bread roll. Whenever I'm in Appleton, this is a go-to spot for me! The sauce is fantastic, the cheese is perfectly balanced, and the dough is incredible. You’ve got to try it!

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

We never vist Appleton without stopping at Sal's for a slice! Generous slices of thin crust pizza. Great variety. Pizza is fantastic and the rolls are amazing. Service is always good. Dining room and restrooms are always clean. Outdoor seating area. Very highly recommend Sal's Pizza!

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

This was a wonderful place. The environment felt very cozy to be in. The pizzas were sold by the slice and their size comparable to the ones sold at wholesale stores loke Costco and Sam's club although of much greater quality. The slices ate baked fresh in front of you and served with a roll on top. Wonderful service and food

Matt 15.08.2024 - 06:38

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The pizza slices are quite large! I ordered two slices, two garlic knots, and a fountain drink, which came to around $16. Everything was delicious, and I particularly enjoyed the BBQ chicken pizza.

Tracy 15.08.2024 - 06:38

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Best Pizza in town!

Feedback