Reviews
What Nancy Mills doesn't like about Mama Jo Homestyle Pies:
Not a major complaint, just important to me. I bought a package of what I thought were plain brownies with a dusting of confectioners sugar on top. Thought I was getting plain brownies but there were chocolate chips in them; I really wanted plain brownies, I don't like chocolate chips. They should label them. Their prices are high, and you should get what you think you are buying. View all feedback. What Jessica Betschart likes about Mama Jo Homestyle Pies:
Lady was rude and rushing me a bit even though it was my first time there. Then asked when my baby is due even though I’m not pregnant it was so embarrassing but the pies were amazing. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
Been getting pies from here a long time and every time I'm back home visiting I have to grab a pie from here.
Pies are phenomenal, but the storefront itself is pretty bare. I was hoping to find pie related items; maybe unique pie pans, travel containers, servers, etc.
Lady was rude and rushing me a bit even though it was my first time there. Then asked when my baby is due even though I’m not pregnant it was so embarrassing b...
read moreThis is nice little pie soup but best dam n pecan pie ever! Worse mistake is I didn't buy couple extra. Taffy was awesome
What a pleasant place to go. They not only have amazing pies butbthey carry lots of other snack foods, drinks, souvenirs and have some seating as well. Everythi...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreI bought a pie from Mama Jo's to bring home to Milwaukee, Wisconsin with me to share with my co-workers. They absolutely LOVED it!! They asked if you offer deli...
read moreThis 4 star rating is for their pies- they are very good. Clean store. The staff or I should say the old lady with short gray hair had a poor attitude and was t...
read moreThis place has been around for a very long time.The pies are phenomenal but not cheap, anything worth buying isn't any more.They're made with top shelf ingredie...
read moreI grew up with this pie place and I've never had a bad pie here. If you haven't been here yet, you NEED to come get yourself a delicious pie! My top favorite ar...
read moreReally good pies and a large selection. Too bad it's so far away. I'd go once a week.
{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more