Mama Jo Homestyle Pies - Amherst

I bought a pie from Mama Jo's to bring home to Milwaukee, Wisconsin with me to share with my co-workers. They absolutely LOVED it!! They asked if you offer delivery, but I see online that unfortunately you don't. I just wanted to let you know that I'm in a clinical setting where doctors even enjoyed it. Would you consider a long distance delivery?? Lol.

This 4 star rating is for their pies- they are very good. Clean store. The staff or I should say the old lady with short gray hair had a poor attitude and was tired that I ordered and left with 4 pies 17.50 each. She kept saying ‘ is that all?’Apparently my money is best spent elsewhere- waiting on me was far too troublesome.

This place has been around for a very long time.The pies are phenomenal but not cheap, anything worth buying isn't any more.They're made with top shelf ingredients and the flavors are unbelievable.Just a guess but I would say they have 50 to 60 different pies on a normal day.That's just on the pies. Then you add the cookies and the smaller cakes and their selection is second to none.Well worth the drive if you're anywhere near here

I grew up with this pie place and I've never had a bad pie here. If you haven't been here yet, you NEED to come get yourself a delicious pie! My top favorite are apple, banana cream and the Strawberry. It pairs perfectly with a cup of coffee! You can't just have one slice! There's over 35 pies to choose from so theres something for everyone! Thank you Mama Jo's!

Really good pies and a large selection. Too bad it's so far away. I'd go once a week.