Reviews

Overall Total Score
4.1 out of 5
Impressive | 84 reviews

What Catherine K likes about Stuart's Seafood Market:
Fresh seafood! Crystal is a guru of the fish! So friendly and helpful! She even helped me with a recipe to make my anniversary dinner so special mussels in wine sauce and a beautiful tuna steak! Thank you!! I look forward to coming back! View all feedback. What User doesn't like about Stuart's Seafood Market:
It’s just not the same under new ownership. Three times we’ve bought whole fish, which has smelled absolutely rancid in under 24 hours after squeezing lemon all over it and stuffing it with herbs to marinate. When you go in to the shop and even if you’re only looking for seafood, make a point to look at the produce…it’s on the cusp of being rotten. What a shame. View all feedback.

Reviews from various websites

Restaurantji
4.1 ★ from 84 reviews

I am happy with the consistently fine quality and freshness of the fish I buy here. The prepared foods are also great.

Sylvia
17.09.2023 - 06:24

Fantastic food great for picking up delicious catered app trays highly recommend!

Catherine
17.09.2023 - 06:24

Fresh seafood! Crystal is a guru of the fish! So friendly and helpful! She even helped me with a recipe to make my anniversary dinner so special mussels in wine...

read more

Fantastic selection! Clam pies (a hyper-local). Possibly the best lobster bisque I've ever had!

It’s just not the same under new ownership. Three times we’ve bought whole fish, which has smelled absolutely rancid in under 24 hours after squeezing lemon all...

read more
Sirved
2.0 ★ from 4 reviews
Andrea
20.01.2024 - 09:13

It?s just not the same under new ownership. Three times we?ve bought whole fish, which has smelled absolutely rancid in under 24 hours after squeezing lemon all...

read more
Robin
20.01.2024 - 09:13

As others have said, it?s not the same. Not even close. Every single order I call in is messed up and when I complain, they?re mad at me like I did something wr...

read more
Jennifer
20.01.2024 - 09:13

This is a sad review to leave since we?ve loved Stuart?s for years. The new owners have just raised prices to where it?s crazy, steamers are $12 or more a pound...

read more
Mark
20.01.2024 - 09:13

If you're thinking anything seafood Stuarts is place . First and foremost they're good people. The seafood is always fresh, local, and if you want lobsters cook...

read more

Good Rated Restaurants near Amagansett

4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.8
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Bridgehampton (near Amagansett), One Ocean RoadNY 11932, Bridgehampton, United States
"Excellent as always, esp the Fat Farmer and the burger."
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.4
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Amagansett, 1980 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, United States
"Very nice restaurant the food was delicious."
4.3
Menu
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Open Now
City: Amagansett, 4 Amagansett Square Dr, 11930, United States
"Really good drinks, excellent oysters and pizza. My gf loved her key Limecake"
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: SAG HARBOR (near Amagansett), Long Wharf, Sag Harbor, 11963, United States Of America, SAG HARBOR
"Delicious fresh seafood. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"
4.2
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.2
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: SAG HARBOR (near Amagansett), 63 Main Street Sag Harbor, NY 11963, 11963-3145, SAG HARBOR, United States
"Yummy food Great service Lovely evening"
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: SHELTER ISLAND (near Amagansett), 55 N Ferry Rd (at Jaspa Rd), Shelter Island, New York, USA, 11964, SHELTER ISLAND, United States
"So delicious and really authentic! Would definitely come again."
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: SHELTER ISLAND (near Amagansett), 23 North Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, New York, USA, 11964, SHELTER ISLAND, United States
"Very good food and pleasant service."
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.6
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: East Hampton (near Amagansett), 143 Main St, East Hampton I-11937-2716, United States
"Great hotel, it's so worth it Rooms: 5 Service: 5 Location: 5"
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.7
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: SHELTER ISLAND (near Amagansett), 41 South Ferry Road Shelter Island, NY 11964, 11964-9700, SHELTER ISLAND, United States
"Karen the server was fantastic! Food was just fantastic."
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
4.3
Menu
Table booking
Open Now
City: Town of East Hampton (near Amagansett), 11 South Emery Street, Montauk, 11954, United States Of America, Town of East Hampton
"Great steaks and service. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"