Reviews - Port Edward

American, Seafood, International

Reviews summary

Nestled by the river, this seafood restaurant offers a delightful dining experience, combining stunning views with a charming atmosphere. Guests are welcomed by a koi pond and can enjoy a diverse menu featuring fresh seafood and indulgent dishes like Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms and a variety of cocktails. While the indoor setting can feel a bit cramped due to frequent server visits, the lively ambiance and outdoor seating make up for it. The restaurant also provides a unique option to dine on a sailboat or in a windmill, ensuring a memorable culinary adventure that brings patrons back time and time again.

Overall Total Score
3.6 out of 5
Very good | 4822 reviews

Was Dessie Reynolds at Port Edward a mag?

I had a great time dining at this restaurant, particularly enjoying the hot dishes. The culinary experience felt authentically traditional, and the entrance adorned with a koi fish pond was a nice touch. However, I found it a bit annoying to be interrupted by a server or staff member every 20 minutes, as it made the atmosphere feel somewhat crowded. Overall, I would definitely come back. They offer an all-you-can-eat... View all feedback.

What Lafayette Breitenberg dislikes about Port Edward:

Port Edward is a go-to spot for seafood. My latest visit was on a Sunday afternoon, where I enjoyed some delicious appetizers after sampling beer at a nearby brewery. View all feedback.

Images uploaded by reviewers

Reviews from various users

Int Restaurants

Last update : 01.05.2026

4.0 ★ from 3058 reviews
rebecca-rose-lawyer4
01.05.2026

I loved the food, especially the hot foods. The dining experience was classy and the front entrance has a coi fish pond. One thing I didn't enjoy was being bumped into every 20 minutes by a waitress or individual because of how crowded the set up is. Overall, I think I'd return it was so good. This is an all you can eat buffet with an exception to the visit being limited to 1.5 hrs.

kristin-riehl-farmer
01.05.2026

We had a blast here! Beautiful location right on the river near the river walkway. We took a quick walk while waiting for our table. Inside, there's a really cute koi pond and a quarter machine with fish food for them, which my kid loved. The seafood stuffed mushrooms were delicious. Definitely check it out!

johnmendezdesign-men-1
01.05.2026

Easter champagne brunch. Had the last seating at 4p. They ran out of everything!!! No food left, no champagne left, grant it we left and didn’t get charged but I still haven’t been refunded my $20.00 reservation fee. So disappointing. I don’t think I’ll ever go back. Spent so much money there last summer and got to know staff. This place needs MAJOR management improvements.

bubblz-1
01.05.2026

It’s been over 15 yrs since I’ve frequented this place with my family. Only outdoor seating available, 50 min wait for Thurs dinner, but great view. The food wasn’t as I remember, just average at best for the pricey dishes and large portions. Good, quick service.

Sirved

Last update : 25.01.2024

3.9 ★ from 1015 reviews
charles-lawhun-1
25.01.2024

We had a fantastic time at this restaurant. We tried the Long Island Ice Tea special, Bombay Sapphire martinis, chilled oysters on the half shell, crab cakes, the Nantucket Bucket of steamed clams, and a side of bread with crab spread. The views were stunning, and the atmosphere was lively. We highly recommend this place!

greg-srabian
25.01.2024

The food and service at this restaurant were outstanding. The owner has adorned the interior with a collection of items gathered over the years, so make sure to take a walk around and explore everything. For a truly unique dining experience, consider reserving a table on the sailboat or inside the cozy windmill, but be sure to plan ahead.

puja-bose
25.01.2024

The seafood at this restaurant is outstanding and fresh. I truly appreciate the island atmosphere here. I highly recommend trying the Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms, Shrimp Alfredo, and NY Strip Steak.

gene-ivanov
25.01.2024

Wonderful spacious outdoor area located right by the river with dock access. Primarily seafood dishes on the menu. Beautiful river views accompanied by live music. Outdoor bar with ample seating available.

rebecca-rose-school5
25.01.2024

I really enjoyed the food, especially the hot dishes. The dining atmosphere was elegant, and the entrance features a beautiful koi fish pond. The only downside was how crowded the space felt, causing me to be bumped into frequently by staff or other guests. Overall, I would definitely return—it was that good. This is an all-you-can-eat buffet, with a 1.5-hour time limit per visit.

Menu

Last update : 14.01.2023

4.0 ★ from 5 reviews
jerod42-1
14.01.2023

I have been a dedicated customer for many years and often travel from Chicago to visit Ziya and his team. The consistently high quality of both the food and service is what keeps me and my loved ones returning.

lafayette12
14.01.2023

Port Edward is a go-to spot for seafood. My latest visit was on a Sunday afternoon, where I enjoyed some delicious appetizers after sampling beer at a nearby brewery.

ofritsch-6
21.10.2022

We had a wonderful time at this restaurant! It's located right by the river, close to the riverside promenade, which provides a lovely setting. After a brief walk, we were seated at our table. Inside, there’s a delightful Koi pond and a vending machine with fish food that my child really loved. The seafood-stuffed mushrooms were incredibly tasty; I highly recommend giving them a try.

amclaughlin-engineer
14.01.2023

Very expensive lunch. $53 for me alone. alcoholic drinks are $10. waitress was attentive, eating was okay, but the money was not worth it. if you have money.

reynolds-dessie
21.10.2022

I had a great time dining at this restaurant, particularly enjoying the hot dishes. The culinary experience felt authentically traditional, and the entrance adorned with a koi fish pond was a nice touch. However, I found it a bit annoying to be interrupted by a server or staff member every 20 minutes, as it made the atmosphere feel somewhat crowded. Overall, I would definitely come back. They offer an all-you-can-eat option, though there is a time limit of 1.5 hours.

Tripadvisor
3.9 ★ from 256 reviews
Yelp
3.0 ★ from 487 reviews
Restaurants
3.0 ★ from 1 reviews

FAQ

These Pictures from Port Edward from Algonquin have been uploaded by the Menu community. They showcase the eatery at Port Edward, its interior, location and of course, fantastic Pictures of the delicious menus from Port Edward.

Good Rated Restaurants near Algonquin