Natty Bumppo's - <a href

Craft, Pan-asian Cuisine, American Cuisine
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Natty Bumppo's

Natty Bumppo's
4.5 / 5 (45 reviews)

Menu

The menu of Natty Bumppo's from 76 courses. On average the courses or drinks on the menu cost approximately $9.6. You can view the categories on the menu below..

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Michelle

Images

Natty Bumppo's Food Natty Bumppo's Outside Natty Bumppo's Drink

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 45 reviews

Was Matt A at Natty Bumppo's a mag?
I'm a regular at this restaurant, but I had an exceptional experience during my visit tonight. My server, Christian, was extremely helpful. The food was outstanding, and the service and drinks were equally impressive. If you find yourself in Cooperstown, make it a priority to check out Natty Bumppos! You won't regret it! View all feedback.

What Nancy I dislikes about Natty Bumppo's:
Placed an online order. Three out of four liked their meal. Probably not enough to order takeout from again, but generally liked what they got and ate everything. Two got the pineapple mango shrimp tacos, one- the blackened chicken burrito, and the fourth — the fresh bowl with crispy tofu. Except for the fresh bowl; the portions were decent. The burrito could make a small meal for two. The sauces provided with all th... View all feedback.

bob-b-forest5
25.07.2024

It’s always a pleasure finding a new restaurant, especially when it turns out to be a gem. We were seated by the owner who is very friendly and welcoming. The atmosphere was fantastic, sitting on an upstairs deck watching the activity around the Baseball Hall of Fame. Our server was very pleasant and fast to take and deliver our order. The beer selection was a nice surprise and served super cold, and my wife enjoyed a great house margarita. The plantains were a shock, best we’ve ever had. Our Cu … – show

kenneth-s-teacher429
25.07.2024

First time there but wont be the last, food was great,owner and staff very friendly, place is nice,dont miss out on this hidden gem

josh-b-beach984
25.07.2024

This shop has assembled the greatest team of ice cream servers the world has ever seen. Basically, the avengers of ice cream.

michelle-w-cactus55
25.07.2024

Good service, good food.

lorrie-a-2
25.07.2024

Good tacos — had the shrimp ones Got three good size ones (not two like other reviewers, and the spice was evident, the mango salsa sweet and tangy. The rice is seriously “minute rice” — which should have at least been real rice for the price. How hard is it for a restaurant to cook up a big vat of real rice for the common side dish? Don’t mind paying for good food, and everything else was fresh or at least flavored well (black beans had chopped pepper and onions), toppings on the tacos well cut … – show

Menu

  • Sides*

    2Oz Pico
    2Oz Pico
    $0.5
  • Tacos

    Bumpo's Taco
    Bumpo's Taco
    $13.8
  • Soup

    Beef Srew
    Beef Srew
    $5.9
  • Lunch Specials

    Daves Dog
    Daves Dog
    $14.4
    Empanada And Soup Lunch Combo
    Empanada And Soup Lunch Combo
    $8.9
    Shut Your Mouth
    Shut Your Mouth
    $14.4

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.