Restaurants in Tisbury

"Oh my gosh the gnocchi was AMAZING. What an amazing meal"

Reviews for the restaurant are quite mixed. Some guests found the food to be subpar, with tough spaghetti and congealed pasta. Others raved about the...

"Fish and chips were fine. At first they looked like they spent too much time in the deep fryer but they were moist and delicate inside. Fish tacos wer..."

Mixed reviews for Garde East on Martha's Vineyard. Customers complained of overpriced menu items, salty fish, and inaccurate charges on their bills. H...

Non-Smoking, View, Beer, Happy Hour

"Great breakfast. Many choices and unique dishes."

Nestled in a cozy ambiance, this breakfast spot impressively caters to both vegans and non-vegans, offering a delightful array of options. While patro...

"Great sushi Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"

A popular spot for vegan options, the restaurant offers delicious custom maki rolls. However, some mishaps with non-vegan ingredients in dishes like t...

"Best food and atmosphere on the Island"

Nestled away from the hustle of Martha’s Vineyard, Little House Café boasts an inviting atmosphere and a varied menu that pleases many. While some dis...

"Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5"

**Waterside Market: A Culinary Gem in Vineyard Haven** Nestled in Vineyard Haven, Waterside Market delights patrons with a diverse breakfast and lunc...

"Great lobster roll, fish (haddock) sandwich and fries."

Takeout, Wheelchair Accessible, Parking area, MasterCard

"The dishes the sauce omg to die for"

At La Choza, generous, house-made burritos and bowls shine—fresh proteins, scratch salsas, and an addictive queso blanco—served quickly by friendly st...

"Very good service and the best pizza I've ever had in America"

"I loved everything I bought! Excellent service!"

"No respect from staff. Took orders from friends before others"

"Good service and good coffee! We will be back!"

"Service: Dine-in Meal Type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 2 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1 "

"The restaurant is on the expensive side, but the food was excellent. My husband claims it has the best ravioli he's ever had. Overall, I would rate th..."

"The food was bland but the great service made up for it!"

Beach Road has received mixed reviews, with some diners disappointed in the dining experience compared to its predecessor, Saltwater. While the ambian...

Humphreys Bakery continues to impress with its exceptional array of donuts and mouthwatering sandwiches, making it a beloved staple. Early risers rave...

"Awesome sandwiches, Love the Gobbler."

"I enjoyed smoothies from this place three years ago while I was working on the island, and I still think about them to this day. I would do anything f..."

Takeout, Outdoor Seating, Delivery, Television

"Food: 4 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5"

"I ordered a potato au gratin, it was very good, thank you"

"Great service y products with very high quality"

"Best pizza on the island!"

Martha's Vineyard boasts a variety of pizza experiences that have left diners divided. While some patrons express disappointment over flavorless, over...

"Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 5"

Located on the bustling Main Street of Vineyard Haven, Fish MV offers a diverse selection of seafood amidst a charming atmosphere. While some diners r...

"During my five summers visiting the Vineyard, this was the worst dining experience I've had. While the staff was friendly and attentive, checking in o..."

"Amazing fudge, and friendly staff. So helpful and they explained the fudge making process while making it... if you ask."

"This restaurant is consistently my top choice. I do wish they had a wider selection of crepes; currently, there's only one savory option with vegan ch..."

"Good pizza, fast, and friendly counter staff."

On this island, a compact pizzeria earns a devoted following for crisp, very thin‑crust pies and standout Greek and Caesar salads. Staff are warm and...