Casey's - Smithton

The place is a complete joke! It's the only gas station in town, and it shuts down every night at 10 PM. I pulled in just before closing, but the unfriendly emp... read more The place is a complete joke! It's the only gas station in town, and it shuts down every night at 10 PM. I pulled in just before closing, but the unfriendly employee saw me and rushed to the door, locking it right in front of me. He even held up his phone to show that it was 10 PM. I won't be wasting my time there again. Have a great day!

I visited the restaurant around noon and observed that much of the food seemed stale, as if it had been left out for a long time. Everything looked brown and wi... read more I visited the restaurant around noon and observed that much of the food seemed stale, as if it had been left out for a long time. Everything looked brown and wilted. My Italian wrap was excessively filled with black olives, which dominated the flavor. The only highlight was the pizza, which was surprisingly quite good.

I always enjoy going there for pizza, peanut butter crisps, and their store-brand chocolate-covered peanut clusters—it's truly my favorite pizza spot. However,... read more I always enjoy going there for pizza, peanut butter crisps, and their store-brand chocolate-covered peanut clusters—it's truly my favorite pizza spot. However, on my most recent visit, I decided to try two chocolate Bavarian long johns. I used a tissue to pick them up and put them in my bag, but unfortunately, I ended up with chocolate all over my hands in the process. By the time I reached my car, which is only about 20 yards away, the chocolate had smeared all over the bag and the tissue, with hardly any left on the donuts themselves. I’m not sure if they need to chill the donuts or something to prevent this, but it was pretty frustrating. I’d estimate that at least 50% of the frosting came off the donuts!

The food at Casey's is excellent, and the store is very clean. They follow all safety guidelines, including mask requirements, sanitation procedures, and protec... read more The food at Casey's is excellent, and the store is very clean. They follow all safety guidelines, including mask requirements, sanitation procedures, and protective glass shields for cashiers. Social distancing markers are clearly in place. The staff creates a cheerful and friendly atmosphere, working hard to ensure you find what you need and are well taken care of. I visit often and always have a great experience.

Once again, Casey's has changed their hours and is now opening at 7 a.m. The owner and management really need to get things sorted out. Between the inconsistent... read more Once again, Casey's has changed their hours and is now opening at 7 a.m. The owner and management really need to get things sorted out. Between the inconsistent hours and the food that’s often stale, I’ll be driving elsewhere from now on.