Casey's - Smithton
Casey's
Menu
On this Homepage, you will find the comprehensive menu of Casey's from Smithton. Currently there are 12 menus and beverages available.
Casey's in Smithton, IL, is a beloved American restaurant with an impressive average rating of 4.2 stars. Open from 5:00 AM to 10:00 PM, Casey's invites you to savor delicious meals crafted to suit a variety of tastes, including options for vegetarian diners. Whether you're planning a visit or would like to make a reservation, feel free to call ahead at (618) 277-0730. Prefer to enjoy your meal at home? Casey's is available for delivery through Uber Eats or DoorDash. Don't forget to share your dining experiences with others by leaving a review!.
Images
Feedback
Casey's, a local gas station and eatery, offers a mixed dining experience. While the establishment is clean and the staff is generally friendly, inconsistencies in food quality and service disrupt enjoyment. Diners have praised the pizza and subs for their freshness, though some menu items appear stale. Additionally, operational hours and staff demeanor have been criticized, detracting from the overall experience. Nevertheless, with excellent sanitation practices and tasty offerings, it remains a spot worth visiting when in need of a quick bite.
I go there about 3 times a week , the workers are nice and fast it has 2 registers and bathrooms they are nice and surprisingly clean. they bake fresh doughnuts and also sell freshly made pizzas, and little cups of hot and ready chicken bits and other freshly made food. they also sell basic items such as candy, chips, bottled drinks,they have a fountain soda and slushes. they also have coffees and soft serve ice cream.
Asked for pizza special. Was told what it was. I repeated what worker said. That was @1pm. Called to order, given special and price, which I repeated. Got to store, was not what I had been told, twice,at different times. Another worker came out and quoted a different price than what I was told. I left all 4 large pizza and drinks at counter. Will never use Casey?s.
This was an AMAZING sub! The bread was fresh and soft. The kitchen was impeccably clean, and the vegetables were incredibly tasty, fresh, and juicy. The gentleman who prepared my sandwich made it look absolutely mouthwatering. I could hardly wait to dig in. The service was very friendly, and he maintained a smile while attentively listening to my order. He definitely deserves a pay raise! The staff was well-dressed, and the sanitary conditions were excellent. It was absolutely worth it to enjoy the food. You definitely don’t want to miss stopping by for a bite, folks!
The place is a complete joke! It's the only gas station in town, and it shuts down every night at 10 PM. I pulled in just before closing, but the unfriendly employee saw me and rushed to the door, locking it right in front of me. He even held up his phone to show that it was 10 PM. I won't be wasting my time there again. Have a great day!
I visited the restaurant around noon and observed that much of the food seemed stale, as if it had been left out for a long time. Everything looked brown and wilted. My Italian wrap was excessively filled with black olives, which dominated the flavor. The only highlight was the pizza, which was surprisingly quite good.
Menu
Drinks
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
Dessert
Starters & Salads
More information
QR-Code for the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.9 / 5 (53 reviews)Chinese ChickenChinese Dragon
South Main Street, Smithton, 62285, United States Of America
"Super sweet employees, fast service, fantastic food. Thanks!!!"
★ 4.1 / 5 (2055 reviews)Casual American Bbq Breakfast WineNo Jacks
4001 IL-159, 62285, Smithton, US, United States
"Saturday morning French toast buffet. Go there!"
★ 3.7 / 5 (366 reviews)Grill Breakfast Cakes Fish BeerMueth's Tavern
2 S Main St, Smithton, USA, United States
"They used to have have great cooks!!!"
