Images
Contribute
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What User likes about My Sugar Pie:
Today came to visit the sweet scenic downtown of Zionsville for the first time today and stumbled over this jewel. Sugar Cream pie is a childhood favorite and this is the absolute best I ever had! Amazing!!! Can't wait to get back! View all feedback.
Today came to visit the sweet scenic downtown of Zionsville for the first time today and stumbled over this jewel. Sugar Cream pie is a childhood favorite and this is the absolute best I ever had! Amazing!!! Can't wait to get back!
I was in town for a wedding. Can I just say WOWZER!! The cake (sugar and Dutch apple were just fantabulous: My experience in this shop was excellent. I have to spend some time getting to know the sweet owner and I can understand why this shop is such a success. I will definitely stop for more cakes when I get in the area (which only has to be on site; Thanks My Sugar Pie for such a wonderful first experience. Terri (from Evansville, IN
The absolutely best Sugar Pie you'll ever eat. Filling is sweet and creamy, crust is perfectly baked. Make sure you order in advance for Thanksgiving Pieces!
The best cake I've ever had! We love the sugar cream cake! Wow.
This is my favorite place in Indiana. Happened to stop in here one day by chance, now I am always looking for an opportunity to go or get a pie!! The absolute best pie I have ever had. Made by Angel's kisses!!!
Full Menu
More information
QR-code link to the menu
