Mill House Inn - Yaphank

Steak Tips, Coffee & Tea, American

Mill House Inn

★ 3.9 / 5 (2131 reviews)

Mill House stands out as a destination for memorable dining experiences, offering an impressive array of American and German cuisine. Ideal for gatherings, such as birthday celebrations, patrons rave about generous portion sizes and flavors that leave guests delighted. Signature dishes like the turkey wraps, German sampler, and mouthwatering crab cake sandwich frequently garner praise. The inviting ambiance, attentive service, and timely delivery further enhance the overall experience. While some dishes may have nuances, such as a sweet ginger sauce, the consistent quality and value make Mill House a recommended choice for food lovers seeking delicious meals by the water.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: Robin

Images

Contribute

Feedback

★ 3.9 / 5 from 2131 reviews

Was Kanishka Wijesekara (Kanishka) at Mill House Inn a mag?
Went to this American/German restaurant by the water with my wife for lunch. The ambience and service is amazing. Plenty of parking too. Had the German sampler and the only thing I liked about it was the bratwurst and the potato ball. The homemade ginger sauce was too sweet for my liking. My wife had the chicken ALA Rachel and that was quite good. Didn't get anything to drink since we were driving. View all feedback.

Kanishka

18.07.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Went to this American/German restaurant by the water with my wife for lunch. The ambience and service is amazing. Plenty of parking too. Had the German sampler and the only thing I liked about it was the bratwurst and the potato ball. The homemade ginger sauce was too sweet for my liking. My wife had the chicken ALA Rachel and that was quite good. Didn't get anything to drink since we were driving.

Will

18.07.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Delicious food, enjoyable martinis, and a charming ambiance. The restrooms are unnecessarily designated by gender since they both have single stalls. It seems like it would be a great time during the summer!

Kevin

18.07.2023

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Seven of us made a reservation and gathered there for dinner. The steak tips as an appetizer were fantastic—at least three of us mentioned we’d consider ordering them as a main course next time. The nachos and scallop appetizers were also excellent. I can’t express enough how delicious the meatloaf was. The service was outstanding. This will definitely be our new go-to spot!

Robin

12.02.2024

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

Delicious food! The indoor dining area is charming and accommodating for groups as well. The service is excellent. There's also outdoor seating available for when the weather is nice.

Jason

12.02.2024

★ ★ ★ ★ ★

The food and service are excellent. The prices are reasonable, and the portion sizes are standard. I would definitely recommend this restaurant.

Reviews