Reviews - Lost Key Tap
Reviews summary
Nestled in Wrightstown, Lost Key Restaurant has quickly become a local gem, captivating visitors with its stunning decor and welcoming atmosphere. Guests rave about the exceptional service, with attentive staff enhancing the dining experience. The drink menu impresses, featuring highlights like a refreshing frose and a remarkable selection of cocktails, including an outstanding Old Fashioned.
While appetizers like the crispy roasted Brussels sprouts are must-tries, main courses can be hit-or-miss, with mixed reviews on dishes like the macadamia nut-crusted walleye. Nevertheless, diners appreciate generous portion sizes and the overall quality of the food, making this a worthy destination for a memorable night out or casual lunch.
Was Kristi Goldsberry at Lost Key Tap a mag?
This was our first time here. The atmosphere is awesome!! Fantastic service. The food was delicious surprisingly quick to receive. Don't let the parking scare you away like I have before. It looked like there would be a wait but there wasn't!! Reservations accepted but we walked in had a great experience!! We said multiple times while we were there that we would definitely be back soon!! View all feedback.
What Siena Terenzio dislikes about Lost Key Tap:
Beef bone marrow was interesting, we loved the bread very much. We had grilled salmon and macadamia nut crusted walleyes and both were just alright. The macadamia nut crust was mushy and we got few fish bones. Espresso martini was a huge disappointment, I couldn’t even finish it. We tried tiramisu for dessert and it’s just okay. Service was amazing though and we love the decor, the building and the atmosphere there.... View all feedback.
Images uploaded by reviewers
Reviews from various users
Last update : 29.03.2024
This was our first time here. The atmosphere is awesome!! Fantastic service. The food was delicious surprisingly quick to receive. Don't let the parking scare you away like I have before. It looked like there would be a wait but there wasn't!! Reservations accepted but we walked in had a great experience!! We said multiple times while we were there that we would definitely be back soon!!
Went to Lost Key Tap the tonight. We did not have reservations but we're there right at 5 so they fit us in! I will make sure to make reservations going forward as it would be a shame to not be able to get in if my heart is set on eating there! My husband and I both shared the bone marrow appetizer. For mains we both had the featured duck dish as you don't always see duck. It was absolutely amazing!! Our server Josh was attentive and helpful! We finished with creme brulee that you could see the dots of vanilla bean in!!! Absolutely a great experience! It was our second visit but we plan on making it part of our regular rotation.
Everything was incredible! The vibe was amazing, the drinks were delicious, the food was excellent, and the service was exceptional! Oh and the burrata appetizer was the best we’ve ever had! We will definitely be back!
Lost Key Tap is a staple close to the Fox Cities! Food is always superb and they have a variety of gluten-free options! Always a favorite spot!
I really enjoyed the walleye but really wanted to try the wagyu burger but they ran out. Disappointed but hopefully I can try it out next time. Great atmosphere and nice
Last update : 03.02.2024
We stopped here yesterday for a late lunch/early dinner. First of all, the interior is lovely and immaculate. We sat at the bar and since it was an odd time of day, had the place to ourselves. The incredibly nice owner greeted and served us. We both ordered the Trout dinner and it was brought out promptly. So delicious! This is one of our new favorite places and it’s just a short drive from Appleton, well worth the trip! Food: 5
Upon entering this stunning and spotless modern restaurant, we were greeted with a friendly smile. The cocktail menu offered a great selection, with standouts being the amazing old fashioned, delightful fall drink, and the best sangria we've ever had. Bartender Amber was accommodating and knowledgeable. We sampled every appetizer, all of which were delicious, but the standout was the crispy roasted brussel sprouts drizzled in a mildly spicy sauce and served with creamy goat cheese. These brussel sprouts are a must-try. Danny and his staff were fantastic, and both the food and cocktail menus were well-crafted and reliable. For a special treat, seek out the special cocktail menu and try the Tobacco bitters cocktail – absolutely incredible.
Wow! This restaurant is absolutely stunning. The service and food are exceptional. It's now my go-to place! Whether you're dining in for dinner, the price per person ranges from $30 to $50. The food, service, and atmosphere all deserve a perfect 5 rating. I highly recommend trying the lkt Burger and Brushetta. There is plenty of parking available with a free parking lot option.
A wonderful experience with exquisite food Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
The restaurant has a good location and serves great food for dinner. The service is rated at 4 out of 5, while the food and atmosphere are both rated at 5 out of 5.
Last update : 05.11.2022
Wrightstown is a small town. the addition of the lost key restaurant in our city is huge, offering qualitatiw high quality food, good portions, a very friendly atmosphere.
So glad we'll get the place tonight! loved the ambiente! classic live music the wein was amazing eating even better! super attentive staff a great place for.
If you want to dine at a unique, everything made from scratch delicious place, look no more. From refreshing proprietary drink recipes, delicious proprietary homemade food and super friendly owners and servers, this establishment has it all. The atmosphere is awesome, there are a lot of tvs and the bar is huge. We were pleasantly surprised how amazing this restaurant was. The owners Danny and Lauren are superb hosts; they always make sure you have what you need and will make sure you love your drinks and food. We tried the Aquaduct crafted cocktail which was perfect. We also had to try the beer battered bacon which you must try, it's amazzzzing. We also tried the 1/2 lb cheeseburger which was perfectly cooked to medium. It had perfect texture and great flavor. It came with 3 large onion rings and beer battered bacon along with delicious fries. If you are near Wrightstown and are looking for a truly delicious and unique experience try The Lost Key. You will not be disappointed! Bravo!
Wow! my man and I stopped for lunch and lost key tap not disappointed. we started with the cheeses as an appetizer and they were.
Great atmosphere! Our service was great. The staff what extremely friendly and happy to be around. Definitely recommend for a nice night out with delicious food!
