Images
ContributeReserve now
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Michael A likes about Cream Valley Custard:
Amazing bacon cheeseburgers and cheese fries building up to the soft serve ice cream for dessert, the only bad thing about this place is when they close at the end of the season View all feedback.
What M m doesn't like about Cream Valley Custard:
Girl employee working tonight 6/17 took it upon herself to loudly say “she was awkward” within earshot of an autistic child who just placed their order. Abhorrent and disgusting. View all feedback.
This place has the best ice cream you'll find! The service is excellent (we especially love the drive-thru window), and you really get your money's worth. The butterfat blend they use makes their ice cream incredibly creamy and delightful.
This charming country spot offers a friendly atmosphere and delicious custard. If you’re unsure about the difference between custard and ice cream, come on down and we’ll be happy to educate you! Plus, we serve jimmies, not just sprinkles.
The ice cream here is fantastic, and the staff is incredibly friendly! They managed to accommodate a last-minute order for our July 4 celebration and were nothing but helpful and warm. The ice cream was absolutely delicious!
I was on my way to Cape May and I stopped to grab a delicious sandwich. I departed and arrived in Cape May to only discover that I left my wallet there. When I called I found that they had it and I drove back to get and it was given back untouched and with a smile! There's good people in the world still and they work at Cream Valley Custard
CASH ONLY LOCATION!!! This place is nice, always busy. They have food off the grill as well as ice cream favorites. Definitely a hang out spot for locals. My favorite is their root beer float!
Full Menu
More information
QR-code link to the menu
