Images
ContributeFeedback
Contribute FeedbackJersey Pizza Co. garners contrasting feedback, highlighting both culinary delights and customer service woes. While many patrons rave about the crispy, flavorful pizzas and fresh ingredients—especially the highly praised margarita and Sicilian pies—others express frustration over cold deliveries and dismissive service. Complaints about rude communications and a lack of accountability leave a sour taste for some diners. Despite this, loyal fans emphasize the welcoming atmosphere and dedication of the staff. Ultimately, Jersey Pizza Co. showcases a potential divide between exceptional food quality and the need for improved customer relations.
Layout/atmosphere *Couple of tables for dine in but more pizzeria than restaurant layout; two TVs; mobster movie pictures on wall Service *Fine Food/drink *Sicilian pie (16 slices) Good; thick, crunchy crust; liked sauce cheese
I?ve ordered from them a dozen times. The past two times the pizza has been delivered cold. I called to tell them and instead of apologizing I get one excuse after the other. They even blamed be for not living close. Before this order I even asked them notto deliver a cold pizza and they said ?don?t worry we got you?. Yeah by they got me, they fooled me again. Terrible service.It?s a shame the pizza this good is ran by people who don?t know how to run a business.
I placed an order for over $130 owner calls me and says because they are busy I will have to wait until for my order to be delivered very rudely and mean! Especially since I spent so much to patronize his establishment. He proceeded to say we wouldn?tget our order until 5pm even so my children were very excited about the order so I still agreed to wait and not cancel my order.He calls me back again because I ordered thru Grubhub and says that we are located too far so they won?t be making the deliveryanyway. He said they were so busy that they couldn?t make our order but he had time to contact Grubhub for any possible reasonto cancel my order! Even if it was too far that was not the initial reason for his bad professionalism and treating a payingcustomer this way. This was my very first experience with this restaurant and I?m glad it will be my last. I would?ve traveledif the service and food was worth it but this man treated us like we didn?t matter. It?s not what you say but how you say it. Iwish I could give negative stars.
I definitely should've read the reviews before ordering. I wanted a Sicilian Pie for the thick crust, and their site says that's what they have. But what I got was no where near any kind of thick crust pizza. The dough and sauce were flavorless, the onlything that made it edible was the pepperoni
Been getting pizza from places in North Jersey for the past 2 years. I WILL NEVER again spend a penny at this unprofessional establishment ever again. The ?owner? is terrible and service is trash. Be aware if they mess up on a pie they won?t give youyour money back
Full Menu
Download MenuMore information
QR-code link to the menu
