American Lobster - Wind Gap

Seafood, Steak, Bbq

American Lobster

American Lobster
4.0 / 5 (1089 reviews)

Description

In a mixed bag of experiences, local patrons share a range of sentiments about their dining outings. While some celebrate delightful meals and attentive service—especially for special occasions—their positive remarks are often overshadowed by tales of long waits, incorrect orders, and lackluster food quality. Many note that despite the restaurant's vibrant atmosphere and potential, service inconsistencies, such as meals arriving at different times and orders being mixed up, detract from the overall experience. While certain dishes shine, particularly seafood offerings, others leave diners disappointed, prompting suggestions to seek alternatives for a more reliable experience.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: BethK

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 1089 reviews
bk-farm
06.02.2024

We decided to celebrate my wifes birthday last night here. Unfortunately maybe just a bad night but we had a bad experience. Almost everyone at our table was not pleased with their food, the service was slow. Some of our complaints the chocken tasted like seafood, noodles undercooked, soupy type seafood dinner. We have visited this restaurant in the past and had a good experience. Food: 2

kim-elwood-3
06.02.2024

My husband and I decided to try the all-you-can-eat crab legs at this restaurant. The first batch that arrived was overcooked and not even warm. We informed the waitress, who promptly brought out a new batch for my husband. When she checked on me, I was still struggling with the crab legs. She quickly returned with a fresh bucket of perfectly steamed crabs. Delicious! From that point on, the meal improved. In the end, they resolved the issue effectively. Service: Dine-in.

victoria-lennox
06.02.2024

The restaurant seemed to be fully staffed but there was confusion about who was serving us. The food had good flavor, but the crab bisque lacked crab meat. The price of a martini was too high at $21. Our appetizer never arrived, and our entrees and salads were brought out in the wrong order. The atmosphere was pleasant and the staff were polite. Despite having a reservation and being 10 minutes late, our table was not cleared upon arrival, even though there were empty tables available.

bethk
25.04.2025

Waitress was friendly and attentive. Food was yummy and correct temps. Just starting to decorate for the holidays and very nice.

danaj
25.04.2025

Excellent food, very attentive and friendly service.

FAQ

As a guest, you can use the WLAN of the restaurant at no extra cost.

The restaurant offers the opportunity to experience sporting events on a TV / screen.

The restaurant is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physical limitations.

The place also takes the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.