American Lobster - Wind Gap

Seafood, Steak, Bbq

American Lobster

American Lobster
4.0 / 5 (1089 reviews)

Description

In a mixed bag of experiences, local patrons share a range of sentiments about their dining outings. While some celebrate delightful meals and attentive service—especially for special occasions—their positive remarks are often overshadowed by tales of long waits, incorrect orders, and lackluster food quality. Many note that despite the restaurant's vibrant atmosphere and potential, service inconsistencies, such as meals arriving at different times and orders being mixed up, detract from the overall experience. While certain dishes shine, particularly seafood offerings, others leave diners disappointed, prompting suggestions to seek alternatives for a more reliable experience.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: BethK

Feedback

★ 4 / 5 from 1089 reviews
bethk
25.04.2025

Waitress was friendly and attentive. Food was yummy and correct temps. Just starting to decorate for the holidays and very nice.

danaj
25.04.2025

Excellent food, very attentive and friendly service.

victoria-lennox
25.04.2025

It’s not that they’re understaffedI just don’t know what exactly anyone was doing. Lots of people milling about, but no one taking our order or checking on us. Food had a good flavor, except I would have really liked if there was some crab in my crab bisque. It was just cream base, no meat. Also, $21 for a martini is absurd. We ordered an app. It never came. Our entrees came out, then our salads. The food runner asked if we needed anything, came back immediately with our salads, but not the items we asked for. The atmosphere is nice. Seems very clean. The staff was very polite. We had a reservation and were 10 minutes late (we called) but a table still hadn’t been cleared when we got there, even though there were plenty of empty tables that could have been cleared. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 4 Service: 2 Atmosphere: 4

theresa-rufo
25.04.2025

Extremely overpriced. Marinara sauce for mussels or mozzarella sticks thick pastry and bitter. Shrimp scampi very greasy took it home and threw it away. Be careful when you order it adds up very quick. Onion soup, Caesar salad absolutely delicious. Service: Dine in Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $30–50 Food: 2 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup

some-thoughts-1
25.04.2025

Best meal I had all year. I live close and never went here and I am glad I did. I usually don’t go out much because I cook better than almost anywhere. Well here I had a meal better than I can make. Is it pricey, a little bit yes. Was it worth it yes for me it was. I went on a Friday and got the last table. Ordered appetizers and food. It all came out fast and one course right after the other. Lobster was really good and hot. Steak was perfectly done. I also got mushrooms and the were flavored well wish I knew what they did with those. Also the butter for lobster and clams was flavorful and above normal grade. Overall super happy, I haven’t written a review in years, but American Lobster earned it. Thanks for the great meal, I will be back again and would recommend it to anyone. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Middle Neck Clams, Surf and Turf

FAQ

As a guest, you can use the WLAN of the restaurant at no extra cost.

The restaurant offers the opportunity to experience sporting events on a TV / screen.

The restaurant is accessible and can therefore also be used with a wheelchair or physical limitations.

The place also takes the common credit cards.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.