Casey's General Store - Winamac
Casey's General Store
Description
The Winamac Casey's offers a range of dining experiences that are, unfortunately, inconsistent. While some patrons praise its tidy environment and friendly service, others express frustration over order issues, such as long waits and unavailability of delivery. The pizza itself elicits mixed reviews, with some finding the crust too thin and service lacking, while others appreciate its taste, citing high standards. Although the establishment enjoys high marks for atmosphere and service, shortages in menu items and communication challenges remain areas for improvement. Overall, the experience at this location varies widely, leaving diners with differing impressions.
Images
Feedback
I tried calling the restaurant multiple times—at 7:30 PM, 7:35 PM, 7:40 PM, 7:45 PM, 7:50 PM, and finally at 8:00 PM—but no one picked up. All I wanted was a pizza.
The only issue I have with the Winamac Casey's is that they're frequently out of items in their soda cooler. Otherwise, the food and service are great. Food: 4/5, Service: 5/5, Atmosphere: 5/5.
I had the worst pizza experience at the Winamac store. The crust was extremely thin, and the service was lacking. They told me it would be ready in 35 minutes, even though there were no other orders. When I returned 40 minutes later, they were surprised that I was already back. I will never order from there again.
One of only a few gas stations open on Christmas Day and serving food.
My dad said coffee was a little too sweet Good breakfast pizza
Menu
Sandwiches
Breaded Pork Or Chicken$2.8Pizza
Starters
Bacon And Cheese Potato Wedges$2.5Kiddie Corner
$2.6Breakfast
Pastry
$4.9
