Picnic Basket - WI

American, Pizza, Sandwiches
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.
Phone
You can call the restaurant via +12623676288

Menu

The restaurant from WI offers 138 different courses and drinks on the menu at an average price of $12.0.

The Picnic Basket Restaurant in Nashotah, WI, is a beloved American dining destination, boasting an impressive average rating of 4.5 stars. Open daily from 8:00 AM to 7:00 PM, this charming eatery invites guests to enjoy a delightful menu that caters to all tastes, including vegetarian options. To ensure you have a spot, it’s advisable to call ahead and reserve your table at (262) 367-6288. For those who prefer dining at home, The Picnic Basket offers convenient delivery through Uber Eats and DoorDash. Discover the flavors that await you at The Picnic Basket Restaurant—where there truly is something for everyone!.

Last update: 11.12.2025 from: Skyler

Images

Picnic Basket Food Picnic Basket Food Picnic Basket Food Picnic Basket Food Picnic Basket Food Picnic Basket Food Picnic Basket Food Picnic Basket Outside

Feedback

★ 4.7 / 5 from 7111 reviews

The Picnic Basket has garnered a mix of reviews, showcasing a spectrum of dining experiences. While many patrons rave about the delicious, fresh sandwiches and the exemplary service, others express disappointment with dishes like the Buffalo Chicken Bacon Wrap, citing a lack of flavor and heat. Meanwhile, some diners highlight inconsistency in pricing and customer service, with anecdotes of pushy staff and poor conduct from delivery drivers tarnishing their visits. Despite these criticisms, the restaurant is celebrated for its delectable menu offerings and allergy-friendly options, making it a popular choice for many eager food enthusiasts.

Fantastic sandwich selection and great taste! Their slaw and kettle chips on the side are great additions. I usually get the aPorkalypse and it’s one of my favorite sandwiches/meals anywhere!

The best sub sandwiches in SE Wisconsin. No one comes close. The bread is always fresh. Their sides and pizzas are also good.

heidi-becker
Heidi 14.11.2023 - 21:20

Delicious! A must go to! Perfect subs and salads and service! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

skyler-donner-2
Skyler 07.03.2025 - 22:43

I love this place so much! Hands down one of the best sandwich shops you will ever go to. The subs are massive and very reasonably priced. Everything is very fresh and it shows in the quality of the food. The service is top notch, they are always walking around checking on all the tables. The food comes out hot or cold rather quickly. It's a great atmosphere by yourself or with company. They always have some really cool specials so there is always something new to try! Word of advice, always get a rice crispy treat, you'll thank me later.

kristine-konitzer
Kristine 07.03.2025 - 22:43

Our first visit to The Picnic Basket was better than expected. The serve subs and sandwiches, but the place itself is cozier than your typical fast food sub shop. Being middle of winter, however, it was chilly inside and we had to leave our coats on throughout the meal. The food was SO good, and the waitress anticipated our needs and was present just the right amount of time. I would highly recommend this place for a casual dinner and get-together.

  • Side Orders

    Family Spiral Pasta
    Family Spiral Pasta
    $11.2
    Medium Spiral Pasta
    Medium Spiral Pasta
    $6.2
    Small Spiral Pasta
    Small Spiral Pasta
    $2.5
    Regular Spiral Pasta
    Regular Spiral Pasta
    $3.7
    Family Cucumber Salad
    Family Cucumber Salad
    $11.2
    Medium Jalapeño Cilantro Coleslaw
    Medium Jalapeño Cilantro Coleslaw
    $6.2

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.