Marcella's - Wheatfield

Pizza, Pasta, Chicken
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Marcella's

Marcella's
4.3 / 5 (1206 reviews)

Menu

On this website, you will find the complete menu of Marcella's from Wheatfield. Currently, there are 11 meals and drinks available.

Last update: 17.01.2026 from: James

Images

Marcella's Food Marcella's Food Marcella's Food Marcella's Food Marcella's Food Marcella's Food Marcella's Food Marcella's Food

Feedback

★ 4.3 / 5 from 1206 reviews

Was Jen Stone at Marcella's a mag?
Came for the first time on Sat. Drove 45 min to try this place out and we were not disappointed. It was VERY busy but all the workers worked quick and efficiently. We ordered a deep dish with low expectations (as the further from Chicago we get the pizza usually isn’t as good in our opinion) but we were very pleasantly surprised with everything about our pizza. The dough was delicious and cooked perfectly, fresh mush... View all feedback.

What David Mitchell dislikes about Marcella's:
I ordered the deep dish pizza on 9-1. The crust was not the same. It was like it didn't rise. I didn't enjoy it this time. I ordered th 14 inch and my wife and I only could eat 2 pieces it was not worth the 32 dollars I paid for it. I'm a long time customer. You must have new workers or something. Just an FYI. View all feedback.

s-p-bush9
25.01.2024

Best pizza around. It's a little pricey. But if you're from Chicago and you actually want your pizza to, you know, not suck or be bland like the others in the area, you'll pay extra for something that tastes great. The atmosphere is so cool with all the panam collections and old airplane memorabilia! If you don't want pizza, their sandwiches are fantastic as well. My only gripe is there's no delivery available to my area that's really not that far away with an unicorporated demotte address.

alex-bokodi
25.01.2024

Best pizza in the area. We won't even bother going anywhere else. If your familiar with St. John and Pascales, it's very similar and actually better!

david-mitchell-4
25.01.2024

I ordered the deep dish pizza on 9-1. The crust was not the same. It was like it didn't rise. I didn't enjoy it this time. I ordered th 14 inch and my wife and I only could eat 2 pieces it was not worth the 32 dollars I paid for it. I'm a long time customer. You must have new workers or something. Just an FYI.

james-robertson-lawy-2
29.07.2024

This restaurant is a fantastic spot in a charming small town in Indiana, perfect for families and friends. The full-service menu offers a variety of options, and there's plenty of parking available in the strip mall. I've enjoyed both takeout and dining in, and both experiences were excellent. The service is polite and reasonably quick, and the prices are fair, all set in a nice ambiance. The restrooms are clean, which is always a plus. Personally, I prefer their deep-dish Chicago-style pizza over the thin crust. The portion sizes are impressive, especially the pasta dishes, which are generously sized. Overall, it's a wonderful dining experience, and I’m sure that after your first visit, you'll want to come back again. Parking is convenient, thanks to the spacious strip mall.

jen-stone
29.07.2024

Came for the first time on Sat. Drove 45 min to try this place out and we were not disappointed. It was VERY busy but all the workers worked quick and efficiently. We ordered a deep dish with low expectations (as the further from Chicago we get the pizza usually isn’t as good in our opinion) but we were very pleasantly surprised with everything about our pizza. The dough was delicious and cooked perfectly, fresh mushrooms, huge chunks of sausage and a perfectly balanced sweet sauce. The garlic rolls were a nice touch and SO good! We will most definitely be back!

Full Menu

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.