Marcella's - Wheatfield
Marcella's
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Marcella's in Wheatfield. At the moment, there are 17 meals and drinks on the menu.
Discover Marcella's, a beloved American restaurant nestled in Wheatfield, IN, renowned for its inviting atmosphere and an impressive average rating of 4.5 stars. Join us today from 11:30 AM to 8:00 PM and experience the delightful flavors we have to offer. To ensure a smooth visit, consider calling ahead at (219) 956-0525 to reserve your table. Relax and enjoy our fabulous selection of beers while savoring exquisite dishes. If you’re curious about similar dining options, be sure to check out Hop Quest Brewing Company and Quiznos. We’d love to hear about your experience—feel free to leave a review!.
Images
Feedback
Marcellas offers a friendly, attentive dining experience with a cozy, slightly dim ambiance. Their pizza stands out as a local favorite—consistently hot, fresh, and generously portioned, making it a go-to choice. Other menu items, like garlic rolls, antipasto salad, and pasta dishes, receive mixed but generally positive feedback, praised for taste and portion size though occasionally lacking seasoning or condiments. While some find the prices a bit high, the service’s warmth and efficiency, including timely orders and attentive staff, are highlights. Gluten-free pizza is available, appealing to dietary needs. Overall, Marcellas is a dependable spot for casual Italian fare.
I couldn't find a way to post another reply, so I'll add my thoughts here instead: my perch arrived warm but not very hot, and it seemed a bit dry, possibly indicating it was cooked a tad too long. Like I mentioned before, it was still good, just not everything I had hoped for. The garlic mashed potatoes, however, were excellent. My wife had the chicken Alfredo and found the noodles to be overcooked, with garlic being the only noticeable seasoning. This may all come down to personal preferences. I would definitely be willing to give it another try.
The atmosphere was good. It's a pizza place. I want to expect more of the food that was great. The service was great, the place was very busy, the staff was friendly.
Best pizza I have had in this area. I've had other items on the menu and they were delicious too. So glad I ordered a large, plenty to take home. Staff is always so friendly. Drinks refilled before you need to ask. This will be my go to pizza from nowon.
The garlic rolls were as good as they have always been. The small antipasto salad did not disappoint!! Out waitress was excellent and attentive. Well done Marcella's!
I ordered the Italian beef sandwich with mozzarella cheese and it comes with French fries. There was a good amount of beef on a good sized bun. However, the beef had no taste whatsoever and the mozzarella cheese was so skimpy I couldn't find it. My husbandordered the half order of pasta Alfredo with shrimp. He said it was good and the portion size was correct for half order.However, it was supposed to come with soup and bread. He got the bread but did not get the soup. Also, no utensils, no napkins,and no condiments, (salt, ketchup for the French fries) so if you plan on eating in the park or the car and you order a lunch togo, better be sure to ask for the items that would allow you to be able to eat the food. The order was ready at the promisedtime so one star for that, and one star for the pasta tasting good. The food was not worth the price we were charged.
Full Menu
Main Courses And Sides
Sides
Salads
Pasta
Entrées
More information
QR-Code for the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.3 / 5 (1206 reviews)Pizza Pasta Chicken Cheese MeatMarcella's
County Road 1200 3854, 46392 Wheatfield, US
"Amazing garlic knots! Friendly staff."
★ 4.2 / 5 (560 reviews)Bbq Grill Casual American PizzaKniman Grill Inc
North CR 900 West 4766, 46392 Wheatfield, US
"The help sucks and they let the worst people in"
★ 4.3 / 5 (1381 reviews)Italian Pizza Vegetarian FriendlyMarcella's Pizzeria
W State Road 10 3854, 46392-7004 Wheatfield, US