Kingston's Fish Market - West Sayville

Used to great but not so Much anymore. Drinks are run of mill and not really creative. Same for the menu.

Great place on a small marina in Sayville. We were in town from California visiting family and stopped here for lunch (we always look for dockside places like this. Views were nice, but the food was better. We got the Mussels in white wine, lobster rolls and fish and chips, all good servings and quality. Well be back next summer

Came here on Friday night . The place is nice on the water , especially if you have a boat . However the food was a stinker . Husband had the clams . I had the crab cakes which was like a mush patty . I ordered the fish and chips for my main ! Tasteless cod that tasted like bad oil . The place is dirty, and the waitress was a crabby patty . She never smiles once . She did however smile at the men she was serving next to us . (Go figure) I won't be returning . Better place on the water ! Pass

Great location, service was adequate, but the food was uninspiring. I had the flounder Ruben which was dry and nothing like a Reuben at all. The lobster bisque was bland, however the seared tuna looked really good. There are lots of better seafood places to eat in this area in my opinion.

I had an amazing experience at Kingstons Fish Market! The customer service was exceptional (thank you, Andy), and the freshness and deliciousness of the food always impresses me. I'm a loyal customer due to their consistently fantastic service and high-quality offerings. I highly recommend it!