Bagel Buzz - West Islip

I recently visited WI Bagel Buzz for the first time and was greeted with a smile right away. The restaurant was busy around 11:30am, but the server was polite a... read more I recently visited WI Bagel Buzz for the first time and was greeted with a smile right away. The restaurant was busy around 11:30am, but the server was polite and answered all my questions with a smile. They went out of their way to ensure I was happy with my order, which was not only perfect but also delicious. The price was reasonable, and I will definitely be returning soon. I even called to express how impressed I was, and learned that the server who helped me was Taylor. She was thoughtful, polite, professional, and knowledgeable, all while maintaining a smile. Thank you again, Taylor! You're a keeper.

I’ve been coming to this location for almost 7months and definitely don’t plan on stopping. Their bagels are very fluffy and fresh, and great customer service!... read more I’ve been coming to this location for almost 7months and definitely don’t plan on stopping. Their bagels are very fluffy and fresh, and great customer service! DEFINITELY recommend.

The staff at this restaurant is fantastic. Despite being short-staffed due to Covid, they all work incredibly hard and are always friendly. As a loyal customer,... read more The staff at this restaurant is fantastic. Despite being short-staffed due to Covid, they all work incredibly hard and are always friendly. As a loyal customer, I always feel like part of the family when I visit. Their bagels are the best on Long Island, and their egg sandwiches are like a cure for sadness, tiredness, and hangovers.

This is my go-to spot for bagels. The best egg sandwiches on the island can be found here. If Bagel Buzz ever closed, a part of me would feel lost because I lov... read more This is my go-to spot for bagels. The best egg sandwiches on the island can be found here. If Bagel Buzz ever closed, a part of me would feel lost because I love their bagels that much. If you haven't already, you should definitely give them a try - they're amazing!

Don't order Uber Eats from this place. They can't even read a simple order and the food is not tasty and not fresh. I order hash brown and omg it tasted a day o... read more Don't order Uber Eats from this place. They can't even read a simple order and the food is not tasty and not fresh. I order hash brown and omg it tasted a day old or even more like refrigerated and then heated up. I ordered a BLT bagel with a chicken cutlet. The chicken cutlet for an extra 3 dollar it was not fresh nor seasoned well. The tomato and lettuce were old. Who enjoyed old bitter tasting lettuce and old mushy tomato. I sure don't smh. I had 5 items ordered and only received 4. I ordered a side of bacon cause my daughter only eats bacon for a breakfast choice and never recieved it. Yes I'll get back my refund for the bacon but that's not the point. I had to pick out my bacon from my sandwich l. The only thing I enjoyed was my ice coffee and it was black smh I added my own creamer and sugar. Even the bottle juice was warm smh. Come on now this is ridiculous. Need to do better!!! I spent $40 to get bad food gtbkm for a fact I will never order or consider purchasing from this place ever again.