Atlantis Diner - West Islip

I visited the restaurant today (June 11, 2023) since my family attended a dance recital nearby. The waiter was friendly, and the food was served relatively quic... read more I visited the restaurant today (June 11, 2023) since my family attended a dance recital nearby. The waiter was friendly, and the food was served relatively quickly, given how busy the diner was.

I experienced terrible service today, even though the restaurant wasn't busy. The food arrived cold, I requested three waters but only received one, and no one... read more I experienced terrible service today, even though the restaurant wasn't busy. The food arrived cold, I requested three waters but only received one, and no one came to check on us or to refill my drink.

We celebrated my birthday dinner here last night, and it's my favorite restaurant because I always get a delicious meal at a great price. I really enjoyed my me... read more We celebrated my birthday dinner here last night, and it's my favorite restaurant because I always get a delicious meal at a great price. I really enjoyed my meal. My only concern...

Clean, great staff, good food. We had a nice meal in a pleasant atmosphere without having to strain to hear each other. read more Clean, great staff, good food. We had a nice meal in a pleasant atmosphere without having to strain to hear each other.

Do you ever get a bad meal at a diner? Food was delicious but the cost was outrageous. A skillet is $21? This is why I don't live in New York. This is nothing a... read more Do you ever get a bad meal at a diner? Food was delicious but the cost was outrageous. A skillet is $21? This is why I don't live in New York. This is nothing against the server nor the quality of the food.