Miceli Brothers Pizzeria - West Babylon

I ordered a sausage parmesan hero and a chicken finger lunch with fries for takeout. The chicken finger lunch was fantastic. However, when I opened my sausage parmesan hero, I noticed there was no Parmesan cheese on it. I called and spoke to Tony, who I believe is the owner. He offered to let me come back anytime for a free replacement hero. I returned three days later, and he made me an excellent sausage parmesan hero. This was my first experience with such great service. Not every meal or person is perfect, but having an owner who truly cares about their business and does the right thing makes all the difference. I now consider this place exceptional and plan to visit regularly.

Fresh made pasta, the special pizza is delicious. Would recommend

I really enjoy this place; it’s beautiful and clean, and they serve authentic Italian pizza.

The food is outstanding! The restaurant has recently been remodeled, and the dining area is currently open, with more updates on the way. At the moment, it has a very comfortable and spacious ambiance. The tables and chairs are quite cozy, which is a significant plus for someone of my size. I’m looking forward to seeing the decor once it’s fully finished, particularly the outdoor area!

The best Pizza Place in Suffolk County. The quality of their food and ingredients used in creating the ultimate culinary experience surpasses the other pizza places. The staff is always friendly and the owner is a gentleman. From Vegetable to Margarita pizza pies and everything in between, they are the “real-deal!”