Reviews - Over/Under

#25 - Seafood - Webster, American, Grill

Reviews summary

At this restaurant, experiences vary dramatically. While some patrons rave about the enjoyable atmosphere, excellent service, and consistently good food—especially the fries and burger options—others have endured frustrating visits marked by unappetizing dishes and long wait times. Reports of cold and poorly cooked food, combined with inattentive service, have left several guests disappointed. Those looking for a lively sports bar vibe may appreciate the extensive beer selection and numerous TVs, but the mixed reviews suggest that diners should proceed with caution before making a reservation. Overall, it's a venue with the potential for fun, but also considerable room for improvement.

Overall Total Score
4.2 out of 5
Impressive | 820 reviews

Was Dianne Manning at Over/Under a mag?

Danielle, the bartender, was amazing! She really shines with her warm personality, excellent customer service, and charisma. Her sense of humor is fantastic, too. She is definitely a tremendous asset to Over/Under! This place is definitely worth a visit, especially with such an incredible bartender. View all feedback.

What S Gonzalez dislikes about Over/Under:

I had a very disappointing experience at this restaurant. I ordered the Three Parlay, but it didn’t actually come with three items as expected. Instead, I got some odd pieces of fried batter that resembled fried pickles, along with dried and slimy boneless wings. The whole meal was quite unappetizing. There are so many better places to eat, so I wouldn’t recommend spending your time or money here. View all feedback.

Images uploaded by reviewers

Reviews from various users

Menu

Last update : 21.03.2023

3.8 ★ from 13 reviews
trace-balistreri-1
21.03.2023

Kristen was absolutely amazing and the food was just as great!! Definitely recommend and I will be safe again!

trace-balistreri-1
30.10.2022

I go here a couple times a week. The food is consistently good and so is the service. Lots of TVs, so good for watching sports event. Great selection of beers on tap.

jose21-1
30.10.2022

I had a great time and reasonable prices my friends however got double charged or over charged so just keep an eye on your tab.

tnicolas-elephant880
30.10.2022

This is a charming place for a casual meal. I've visited a couple of times, and although the service can be a bit slow, it's definitely worth the wait. I look forward to coming back again!

zjacobi-elephant2
30.10.2022

Made one visit and ate at the bar. I found it very unimpressive. The food was okay, and the service was mediocre at best. First visit will be my last visit.

Restaurantji

Last update : 17.12.2023

2.4 ★ from 10 reviews
jens-jensen-2
17.12.2023

4 of us went for drinks and dinner. Ordered an appetizer too. It was the worse food and service I have had in a long time. It was 5pm on a Wednesday, not crowded and 3 people working. Ordered Queso and chips, over 40 minutes to hit the table and was cold. One person had to go to the bar to get his beers. 3 of us ordered food, the first order was shrimp and fish it was cold, under cooked. I did not eat it. All ordered at the same time, the last order was tacos that were clearly burnt. The waitress said she would take them off the ticket, he put them on the table behind us, said they smelled BAD!. Terrible service and the food was beyond bad. J.J.

ed-g-office5
17.12.2023

I've been enjoying Over Under at lunchtime. The menu has a good variety. The food is good and the service is top notch. Its a nice place to go, have a brew/drink, decent food and get together with friends.

heriberto-martinez-2
17.12.2023

Stopped by on a recommendation, and was glad I did. The fries were great, and had a really tasty seasoning, and the burger was nice and juicy.

heather-m-library227
17.12.2023

Pretzel was overcooked. It was small for the price. The atmosphere was un- nerving. I'm all cool with the sexy stuff outfits but soft porn! Absolutely ridiculous!

s-gonzalez
17.12.2023

I had a very disappointing experience at this restaurant. I ordered the Three Parlay, but it didn’t actually come with three items as expected. Instead, I got some odd pieces of fried batter that resembled fried pickles, along with dried and slimy boneless wings. The whole meal was quite unappetizing. There are so many better places to eat, so I wouldn’t recommend spending your time or money here.

Sirved

Last update : 13.01.2024

5.0 ★ from 5 reviews
victoria-hogue
13.01.2024

Absolutely love this bar and grill! they have great prices and the food is delicious. Anel was our bartender/server and we had excellent service. She was very friendly and helpful. We will definitely be back again! Highly recommend!

robert-alston-1
13.01.2024

This is a great place for friends and family that enjoys a bar and grill atmosphere. Catch the games or the fight on the 22+ TV?s surrounding the bar. The gentleman that took our order and worked the bar was awesome and so funny. I think his name wasDavid and it was well worth the dinner experience. Food was good as usual and always have a great time eating here.

richard-rashall
13.01.2024

This spot is ideal for watching games and spending time with the best bartender in town, Danielle Dowden! She creates some incredible drinks and always provides exceptional service, paired with a friendly smile and a dash of sass!

james-johnson-cactus-3
13.01.2024

This restaurant is perfect for gatherings of any size, whether you're dining alone or with a group of twenty. The ambiance is fantastic and completely smoke-free. The staff is very attentive and eager to accommodate any special requests for food or drinks. Overall, it's a great local sports bar!

karen-nadine
13.01.2024

The restaurant has a nice atmosphere, resembling a dining establishment more than a bar. The liquor selection is somewhat limited; for example, they didn't have Tanqueray. However, the food was quite enjoyable. We began with chips and salsa, and then we ordered the chicken quesadillas, which I highly recommend!

Yelp
3.9 ★ from 16 reviews
Restaurantguru
4.7 ★ from 473 reviews
Int Restaurants
4.7 ★ from 303 reviews

FAQ

From Webster, these Photos of Over/Under were uploaded by the members of Menu. They display the dining hall at Over/Under, the interiors, the location and naturally, superb Photos of fine menus from Over/Under.

Good Rated Restaurants near Webster