Flaherty's Three Flags Webster
Menu
Here you will find the menu of Flaherty's Three Flags Webster in Webster. At the moment, there are 37 dishes and drinks on the menu.
Flaherty's Three Flags Inn in Webster, NY is a charming Irish restaurant known for its cozy atmosphere and delicious cuisine. With an average rating of 3.8 stars, it's a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. Stop by today between 11:00 AM and 10:00 PM to experience their menu of traditional Irish dishes. To inquire about availability or make a reservation, give them a call at (585) 671-0816. If you enjoy their menu, be sure to explore similar options at Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria and Mark's Pizzeria. Share your dining experience by leaving a review!.
Images
Feedback
Flaherty’s in Webster is a neighborhood pub known for reliably satisfying comfort food—especially its lobster bisque, prime rib, Reubens, burgers and hearty sandwiches—paired with a diverse beer selection and community-minded vibe. A roomy dining room and a patio with fire pit and fountain make it great for families, dates, and late nights. Service is generally attentive but can be slow at times and bar service uneven; prices have risen, yet daily specials and consistent quality keep customers returning.
We went early on a Friday night and sat in the bar area at a high top. Our waitress was very attentive and friendly. We ordered our food and it came out quickly and was awesome. I used to come here all the time, years ago when I worked in Webster, it was a great place then and is also still great now! They have a large outside deck if you want to enjoy the warm sunny weather while you are out for a drink and bite to eat. You won't be disappointed here, there's a reason they have been in business forever!
I’m from out of state but frequently visit the area to see family. We stopped by here late at night after a long day of driving and spending time with relatives. The patio was fantastic, featuring a fire pit on one side and a water fountain on the other, which was perfect for the autumn-like chill in the air. Our server, Steve, was very friendly, and the food was quite tasty. My spouse enjoyed his steak. I highly recommend the spumoni bomba dessert—it’s a must-try! Although we didn't order the lobster bisque this time, I know it’s excellent. And definitely get the Irish Coffee with both Bailey's and Jameson; you won't be disappointed!
My son came in town on a business trip and wanted to take me for dinner last night, so I chose Flaherty's since they have outdoor seating! The day was very hot, so we ended up eating inside. The super large dining room has tables well spread apart for covid safety and the food was amazing! The lobster bisque was the finest I have ever had and was loaded with lobster and the shrimp scampi with broccoli over linguine was totally amazing as well!! Can't wait to go back!!
The lobster bisque was fresh, velvety, and rich—truly delightful! The staff were prompt and attentive. I highly recommend asking for Drew; he provided excellent service! Our drinks came quickly. Although I typically view pubs as places for drinks and snacks, I would definitely suggest this spot for a family meal as well.
I had a very disappointing experience at Flaherty's Three Flags Webster. We encountered long waits to be seated, slow service, and a significant delay before our food arrived. My fish was overcooked and dry, and the coleslaw was inedible. When I contacted the owner to express my concerns, her reply was rude and dismissive. Instead of addressing the issues, she insulted me, accused me of being rude, and told me not to return. Naturally, I won’t be coming back. My two friends with me had similar negative experiences. I’m not seeking an apology or compensation. Barb, you might want to try other restaurants instead.
Full Menu
Scotch Whisky / Irish Whiskey
Steaks
Hot Drinks
Soups
Chicken
Fish Dishes
More information
QR-code link to the menu

This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.6 / 5 (1876 reviews)Cafés Breakfast-brunch Coffee AmericanMama Lor's Cafe.
Ridge Road 1891, 14580 Webster, US
★ 4.3 / 5 (7513 reviews)Juice Coffee Vegetarian FriendlyThe Waffle Factory
North Avenue 30, 14580 Webster, US
★ 4.4 / 5 (1073 reviews)Dairy-free Options Ice Cream ShopCold Stone Creamery
Ridge Road 1028, 14580 Webster, US