Fire Crust - Webster

Food, Casual, Desserts
Menu
Full menu with pictures, prices and categories.

Fire Crust

Fire Crust
4.5 / 5 (71 reviews)

Menu

On this homepage, you will find the complete menu of Fire Crust from Webster. Currently, there are 17 menus and drinks available.

Fire Crust in Webster, NY, is a highly-rated American restaurant, known for its inviting atmosphere and delicious cuisine, with an impressive average rating of 4.6 stars. Open daily from 11:30 AM to 8:30 PM, it’s advisable to call ahead at (585) 537-4747 to secure your table and avoid any wait. For those who prefer to enjoy their meal at home, Fire Crust is also available for delivery through Uber Eats, offering a wide range of menu options, including delicious vegetarian selections. Looking for similar dining experiences? Be sure to check out Empire Pub and SPIEDIElicious. If you’ve visited Fire Crust before, we’d love to hear your thoughts—leave a review!.

Last update: 01.03.2026 from: nihit

Images

Fire Crust Food Fire Crust Food Fire Crust Outside Fire Crust Menu Fire Crust Menu Fire Crust Inside Fire Crust Food Fire Crust Outside

Feedback

★ 4.5 / 5 from 71 reviews

Was John H at Fire Crust a mag?
Overall, we had a pretty good dining experience. Here’s what my wife and I enjoyed: the location is conveniently situated near the main road (Empire Blvd in Penfield, just west of Webster) in a charming plaza that has been beautifully remodeled with a barn wood theme. The outdoor patio is delightful, featuring a small gazebo and a lovely garden. We decided to order the Chicken Pesto pizza from the menu instead of bui... View all feedback.

What Jimmy M dislikes about Fire Crust:
First, I have tried the Henrietta location a few years back and it was good. So I thought I’d give this new location a chance.But this pizza place is not good at all. It is literally comparable to Red Baron frozen pizza!!!!!! The dough is dense and soggy for a thin crust).I ordered a plain cheese pizza $9.75) and a “I’m meating” pizza $13.95). But realized the cashier actually charged me for 2 “create your own pizza”... View all feedback.

john-h-farmer34
19.11.2023

My family loves trying new Pizza places and Fire Crust definitely stands out amongst all. It checks out every box of a Pizza lover?s dream pizzeria. Quality pizza prepared with fresh ingredients with a little bit of love from super friendly staff, in one of the cleanest kitchens I have seen. We ordered a Paneer Tikka Pizza and a ?make-your-own? style pizza. Both of them came out to be super delicious. And the best part is the quick serving time. It takes time no more than what

john-h-church07
19.11.2023

Ordering was pretty quick as we just chose items off the menu, rather than creating our own. Pizza was ready in 10 mins or so. They call you up to pick up your pizza. Pizza tasted pretty good overall, wasn't mind blowing. For us, the draw was Pittsford Dairy Farm ice cream. Cute outside eating area.

darlene-smythe
12.03.2024

We had a group of about 15 people. It had a great variety of pizza suggestions a n d would put any pizza toppings you want all the same price. It was very good pizza and great to try all kinds of combinations. They have a space that is easy to have a good size group easily. The service was good and the food was great. A good time for all.

nihit-patel
04.06.2025

Iv been to this location a few times and there's always that one reason I come back. Great pizza! Toppings are fresh, prices are great , and always perfect temperature to eat. Lots of seating in the front to enjoy your quick slice as well. The staff arevery friendly and the owner always greats with a smile. If you are looking to try something new, checkout fire crust Pizza, youwon't be disappointed!

kate-macallister-1
04.06.2025

What a great experience! The staff was so friendly plus you got to watch them make the pizza, which ended up being delicious!!! I highly recommend the Mac and cheese one. Try to save room for dessert because their snicker sundae is the cherry on top (witha cherry on top). We'll definitely be back. Very clean and an adorable outside area with picnic tables and a gazebo. Loved theoverall atmosphere.

More information

Suggested nearby restaurants.