Bill Gray's - Webster

The burger was dangerously undercooked. I didn't realize it until I had taken a few bites and noticed it had an unusual taste. Additionally, the bottom of the b... read more The burger was dangerously undercooked. I didn't realize it until I had taken a few bites and noticed it had an unusual taste. Additionally, the bottom of the bun was wet with raw myoglobin, indicating it was assembled on a surface that had come into contact with raw meat. I saw another customer experiencing the same issue while I was there, so it's clear this isn't an isolated incident.

Great service and food . There is an Abbot's frozen custard in most restaurant as well. read more Great service and food . There is an Abbot's frozen custard in most restaurant as well.

Bill Gray 's must have been the World 's Greatest Cheeseburger in 1955. In 2024, it is still pretty good, and I 'd take it over any of the national chains in to... read more Bill Gray 's must have been the World 's Greatest Cheeseburger in 1955. In 2024, it is still pretty good, and I 'd take it over any of the national chains in town. However, please note that the World 's Greatest claim is in dispute because it has not evolved with the times.What I really liked about this place were the historical art and photos on the walls. As a visitor to Webster, I enjoyed connecting with the history of the early settlers of the area.

The fish fry at this location used to be fantastic, but it has declined recently. It seems like the Ontario manager has been transferred to Webster, or perhaps... read more The fish fry at this location used to be fantastic, but it has declined recently. It seems like the Ontario manager has been transferred to Webster, or perhaps upper management changed some policies. The fish was overcooked, the fries were undercooked, and the coleslaw was disappointing. Additionally, there was only one small cup of tartar sauce for a large fish fry. There are better fish fry options in the area, even if they're only available on Fridays, so I will be looking elsewhere from now on. The cheeseburger, which used to be excellent, has also changed; it's now thin and lacks the flavor it had years ago.

I have been visiting this location since high school. Every time I come back to visit Webster I stop in for a Worlds Greatest Cheeseburger and every time it is... read more I have been visiting this location since high school. Every time I come back to visit Webster I stop in for a Worlds Greatest Cheeseburger and every time it is fantastic. Highly recommended this location. They have done an excellent job for a very long time.