Stars Sandwich Market - Warren Park

This place is permanently closed. Nowhere here does it say this and you can still order through the website. I ordered online and walked over. The door is locked, shades drawn, and a look inside showed that it was empty. No equipment, seats or people.

Updated! Seems there was some confusion on my part through the ordering process and the owner has refunded me after a failed pick-up order. Be warned that although the Square app gives pick-up as an option, it really is delivery only! I should’ve been more discerning reading the description but it can be a bit confusing if you’re rushing. If it’s possible for them to remove that option from their site I think it could help to avoid future confusion such as mine. Also would be very helpful if the phone number listed worked! But thank you to the owner for clearing things up in the end and refunding things quickly after I posted a review. I have ordered from this location previously for delivery and the Cheesesteak and fries were really delicious! It’s unfortunate that my more recent attempt to purchase from here was so frustrating, but I plan to order (delivery) again in the future, and I hope they can work out some of the ordering kinks to avoid future mixups such as my own.

Just ordered from this place for the first time and they have royally screwed my order up. Ordered 3 sandwiches and only received 2. Of the 2 sandwiches i received, they have added every extra condiment possible, that i did not order on my sandwich and now cannot eat. I’m pregnant and now have wasted not only money on this garbage restaurant but also time that could have been spend getting food from a restaurant that pays attention to orders. Also…..$3 for a 2 oz container of potato salad…..????? Also let me note that their storefront has moved and isnt updates through uber eats or Grubhub…. More wasted time. Save your money folks! (picture is of the $3 cup of potato salad)

I ordered a ceasar salad expecting a salad the size of the ones pictured in the other reviews. This is what I got for $8....

The kitchen is disgusting and they have cockroaches so don't recommend!