Reviews
What User doesn't like about New Bethel Ordinary:
The staff here are very friendly and attentive. The pizza looks great and is generously topped with cheese and other ingredients, but unfortunately, it lacked flavor. We had to wait quite a while for our food, and it seemed like they focused more on the diners who were already seated rather than those who were waiting for takeout. I noticed several people coming and going while we waited. View all feedback. What User likes about New Bethel Ordinary:
The food is excellent, and the service is friendly and welcoming. There’s a separate bar area, and both spaces have multiple TVs. The menu offers a variety of tasty options, from pizza and wing sandwiches to ham and beans. The side salads are quite generous, and the prices are reasonable. View all feedback.
Reviews from various websites
I’m a fan of the deluxe pizza, but the restaurant is full of house flies. Bring your swatter.
Very nice old restaurant. Been going there since 1968 when it was Curlys!!
We ordered a tenderloin sandwich with fries and the wings 10 of them with the 9 grab. They were burnt hard. The tenderloin sandwich was soggy and the fries were...
read moreThe pizza is some of the best I have ever had! It costs more than most other places, but I argue that you are paying for quality. Everyone in my family loves th...
read moreThis is an excellent restaurant in Wanamaker, and I thoroughly enjoyed my experience dining there. The food and service were outstanding. I ordered the Deluxe P...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreAmazing pizza, Amazing people, at a great price. They have wings, bbq, sandwiches, salads and they serve it right! Large portions
Our family hadn't been here since the 1980s and decided to stop by for pizza and a beer. Let's just say, we were heavily disappointed. From what I've since lear...
read moreI ordered a extra large supreme pizza. I receive my pizza under topped and undercut and not the cut that I specifically asked for. The price of the pizza went u...
read moreThis is a fully loaded pizza pie! My hubby and I ordered the meat lovers and it was beyond our expectations, It is different from traditional pizza, the meat lo...
read moreThis is Indiana Pizza. Holy cow, this is the heaviest pizza you can find without a top crust. It's impressive how much they fit on there. I saw a couple with a...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read moreThis is a fantastic pub for a meal or a drink, featuring an expanded patio. I ordered a quesadilla with added pulled pork for lunch, and it was enormous and inc...
read moreI have dined at New Bethel Ordinary several times, and each visit has been delightful. Most recently, I ordered a 16-inch pizza along with wings #9. The wings w...
read moreIt appears that I've consistently had a great experience whenever I visit this place, and tonight was no exception. This is my first time writing a review on Ye...
read more{{ slotProps.result.comment | strip_tags | str_limit(160) | ucfirst }}
read more