Images
Contribute
Feedback
Contribute Feedback What Nikki J likes about Old Colony Pizza:
I have become tired of New Haven style pizza. This led me to a search for something that was more NY style. I was going through Wallingford on my way home and stopped to get a Spinach/Pepperoni pie. I was pleased with the size of the Medium, and it fulfilled my wishes for the kind of pie I grew up with. I can't wait to get back and try some of their house combos. View all feedback.
What Brianna Collin doesn't like about Old Colony Pizza:
Deliver handled well but I did not receive dressing for my Ceasar salad....sooooo do you not give dressings with your salads? Was more than confused. So. Now I have a dry Ceasar salad. Pretty bummed. Pizza was phenomenal View all feedback.
Really good pizza, nice, friendly, people. Excellent customer service! Give this place a 5+ Stars!!
Excellent service always in person and on the phone. We ate inside and the buffalo chicken salad was one of the best I've ever had!
Always great no matter what we get, pizza, pasta, sandwiches all service with a smileKid-friendliness: We have taken our grandchildren there and the staff is very accommodating and remembers allergy restrictions.
I have become tired of New Haven style pizza. This led me to a search for something that was more NY style. I was going through Wallingford on my way home and stopped to get a Spinach/Pepperoni pie. I was pleased with the size of the Medium, and it fulfilled my wishes for the kind of pie I grew up with. I can't wait to get back and try some of their house combos.
I am New Haven grown so pizza , thin crust pizza is a favorite of mineToo much oil ants me , low grade cheese is disgusting and adds to the oilWe purchased three slices of cheese and several knotsI had to take a quick picture before it was all gone And on top of good food , family operated they are open on Mondays!! Try it you'll like it
Full Menu
Chicken
Pizza
Salads
This restaurant offers dishes containing these ingredients
These Types Of Dishes Are Being Served
More information
QR-code link to the menu
