Matthews Diner - Waldwick
Menu
The menu of Matthews Diner from Waldwick contains about 39 different dishes and drinks. On average you pay about $11.6 for a dish / drink.
Mathews Diner offers a nostalgic experience reminiscent of classic New Jersey diners, characterized by a familiar menu and attentive service. While many patrons appreciate the delicious pancakes and family-friendly atmosphere, there are mixed reviews regarding consistency in food quality and order accuracy. Though the staff is generally friendly, some guests have reported disappointing interactions, particularly with takeout orders. Despite occasional issues with cleanliness and wait times, the diner remains a beloved local spot, fostering traditions and memories for families, and consistently delivering on the expectations of a traditional diner experience.
Images
Feedback
Was User at Matthews Diner a mag?
I absolutely love coming here on Sundays! You serve the best pancakes! My daughters enjoy this place so much that it's become a tradition for us to wake up and come here every Sunday. As a family of four, we really appreciate it! The food is fantastic, and the staff is wonderful. I haven't had a single bad experience so far—definitely not one! View all feedback.
What Thomas Reiche dislikes about Matthews Diner:
While it's a run-of-the-mill diner that, if you live in or frequent New Jersey, it will remind you of others that you've been to.Food was OK, and the service was good! Nothing was really a standout, though. View all feedback.
I ordered the Nova Benedict, and it was one of the best breakfasts I've ever experienced.
The food was outstanding, with generous portions and cooked to perfection. The lunch specials offer great value. It's refreshing to discover a diner that truly takes pride in the food they serve. Although it was busy, the service was excellent, thanks to the numerous staff members available. As of my update in September 2024, this diner continues to impress! It may be slightly on the pricey side, but it’s definitely worth the visit!
I called in for takeout and ordered a bacon cheeseburger deluxe. Unfortunately, I didn't realize until after I left that they gave me just a cheeseburger deluxe without the bacon. Additionally, there was no utensil pack included for my sides, which I have received in previous orders. The customer service was quite disappointing; the man who took my order over the phone and handled the payment when I picked it up was not friendly at all, despite the fact that I tipped for my pickup order.
Food came out quickly and was well prepared, but they don’t let you substitute french fries for a side salad which was new to me. They should add kids mac and cheese to the menu if possible as well.
This is a great diner! They do a nice job here!
Full Menu
Wrap Specials
Capri Wrap$14.9Starters
Texas Chili$7.9Soups
$4.9Healthy Wraps
$14.9Sandwiches
$9.7Salads
$15.9
More information
QR-code link to the menu
This restaurant offers
Suggested nearby restaurants.
★ 4.4 / 5 (3630 reviews)#31 Pizza in Waldwick Italian SaladLimoncello
Franklin Turnpike 32, 07463 Waldwick, US
"Good and service always excellent! The staff is always welcoming."
★ 4.3 / 5 (3016 reviews)#16 Pizza in Waldwick ItalianNellies Place
Franklin Turnpike 9, 07463 Waldwick, US
"Suggestion: It would be great if you could offer meat-free and ice-free options in your soups, salads (like stir-fried broccoli rabe), burgers, appeti..."
★ 4.5 / 5 (1212 reviews)Asian Japanese Sushi Lunch ChickenMoshi Moshi
Franklin Turnpike 137, 07463 Waldwick, US
"Great food and good service. In any case, it'll go again."