Shell Shack - Menu

This is the best seafood I've ever had! The restaurant was spotlessly clean, and the service was incredibly attentive. I had a few questions about the menu, and... read more This is the best seafood I've ever had! The restaurant was spotlessly clean, and the service was incredibly attentive. I had a few questions about the menu, and the waiter patiently took the time to explain everything. He also made sure to keep an eye on our table. Our order was prepared perfectly and tasted amazing! It’s my favorite seafood restaurant in Tyler!

This is the first time I've ever given a restaurant a 1-star rating! DO NOT EAT HERE! I’m usually not one to complain and I typically focus on the positive, so... read more This is the first time I've ever given a restaurant a 1-star rating! DO NOT EAT HERE! I’m usually not one to complain and I typically focus on the positive, so let’s start with the good: the calamari was nice and crispy, though it could have used a bit more salt. However, I’m genuinely concerned that my husband might end up with food poisoning. He ordered oysters on the half shell, which arrived on a plate of ice but were at room temperature. He usually finishes every oyster, but he could only handle 6 this time. The boiled dish tasted overwhelmingly of chili powder and was overcooked by about 10 minutes, making it very difficult to peel. We managed to eat just one shrimp before deciding to leave. The total bill was $234.00! What a complete waste!